1 2
person x: Have you been imprisoned all these years?
person y: Yes, I have/Yes, I was.

What I want to ask is, what happens when one person says something that contains present perfect, and the other person answers using past simple.
Is it okay?
Full Member393
WesternAmericanperson x: Have you been imprisoned all these years?
person y: Yes, I have/Yes, I was.

What I want to ask is, what happens when one person says something that contains present perfect, and the other person answers using past simple.
Is it okay?


person x: Have you been in prison all these years? (IMO, 'in prison' is more appropriate.)
person y: Yes, I have.


You've to follow the verb in the question, which is 'Have'.
Veteran Member8,069
Hmm, interesting question Westerner.

I'd say both "Yes, I have" and "Yes, I was" are possible in that situation and maybe almost equally good, but I'm not sure, as always. Emotion: smile
Veteran Member5,652
Retired Moderator: A moderator who has retired.Trusted Users: Trusted users are allowed to use additional capabilities of the site such as private messaging to all users and various other advanced features. You cannot join this role unless you are promoted by an administrator.
<<what happens when one person says something that contains present perfect, and the other person answers using past simple.>> Here's what happens. The person who answers is punished by the grammar police. Emotion: smile

CJ
Veteran Member51,723
Moderator: A super-user who takes care of the forums. You have the ability to message a moderator privately should you wish. These users have a range of elevated privileges including the deletion, editing and movement of posts when needed.Proficient Speaker: Users in this role are known to maintain an excellent grasp of the English language. You can only be promoted to this role by the Englishforums team.
CalifJim<<what happens when one person says something that contains present perfect, and the other person answers using past simple.>> Here's what happens. The person who answers is punished by the grammar police. Emotion: smile

CJ

Grammar police. It's frightening. W.A., you'd better be careful.
What's wrong with my grammar?Emotion: sad
Strictly speaking, what's wrong about the grammar police? They are just doing their job; In fact, I feel a lot of sympathy towards officer Liat and officer Jim.
Anonymous:
CONVERSATION = = =

Patient: Good morning, doctor ! Can you spare me a few minutes?

Doctor: Certianly ! Come in and sit down. Now, what is the matter with you?

Patient: I've caught a cold, and I'm constantly coughing.

Doctor: You aren't running a temperature, are you?

Patient: I suppose I'm not.

Doctor: Let me examine you... Your heart and lungs seems to be all right. Now open your mouth wide... Now breathe in deeply through the nose... There doesn't seem to be anything radically wrong with you. But you are a little run down. Take a complete rest. Get these tablets thrice a day. You should be all right in three or four days.

Patient: Thank you, doctor.

Doctor: Not at all.
The problem is that you have used phrasing for casual conversation between 2 friends, not between doctor and patient, which must be more formal.

Patient: Good morning, doctor! Thank you for seeing me.

Doctor: Sit down. Now, what seems to be the problem?
Patient: I've caught a cold, and I'm constantly coughing.
Doctor: Do you have a temperature?
Patient: I don't think so.
Doctor: Please remove your shirt... Your heart and lungs seems to be all right. Now open your mouth wide... Now inhale... There doesn't seem to be anything seriously wrong with you, but you are a little run down. Take a complete rest. Take one of these tablets three times a day. You should be all right in three or four days.
Patient: Thank you, doctor.
Doctor: Not at all.
Veteran Member88,631
SystemAdministrator: A system administrator takes care of the inner workings of the entire system. These users have the ability to promote, ban and modify other users.Teachers: Users in this role are certified teachers. This may include DELTA, CELTA, TESOL, TEFL qualified professionals. Email a scan of your qualification to an admin, if you wish to be considered.
Anonymous:
Emotion: stick out tongue Yes I want to say something that all person made by god and we are people creature in this world so I dont know properly what good and what bad.
Show more
Live chat
Registered users can join here