A gate around the entire city

   Share on Facebook  
Angliholic  #489229  Sat, 15 Mar 08 01:59 PM

The city plans to put up a gate around the entire city to make it more closed in and private.

 

HI,

Does the above make sense to you? If yes, what does it mean? If not, how would you make it right? Thanks.

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Feb 14 2007
SomewhereinFormosa
Veteran Member (5,659)
Without true love, life is meaningless and worthless since our physical world is nothing but a dream. ~~Angliholic~~簡瑞達
Philip  #489244  Sat, 15 Mar 08 03:32 PM
Angliholic

The city plans to put up a gate around the entire city to make it more closed in and private.


HI,

Does the above make sense to you? If yes, what does it mean? If not, how would you make it right? Thanks.

The city plans to put up a gate around the entire city to make it more secure and private. [Does that come close to what you wanted?]
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
USA Pacific Northwest (Seattle)
Veteran Member (6,492)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
At reise er at leve! - H. C. Andersen
ganesh77  #489254  Sat, 15 Mar 08 04:12 PM
sounds fine to me (except, perhaps, for the repetition of the subject in the main clause)

 

Main clause: The city plans to put up a gate around the entire city

'To'-infinitive clause: to make it more closed in and private.

 

The people of the city want to keep someone or something in or out of the city. By putting up a gate around the entire city, they will make the city more private. 

The city will then be 'closed in' because the space of the city will be separated from the space outside the city. 'Closed in' meaning an enclosed area.

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Mar 10 2008
Vancouver, Bangkok
Junior Member (52)
The principle which now replies I don't know what was there a hundred years back, the same principle also says that it was unaffected when the whole universe was destroyed....
Angliholic  #489257  Sat, 15 Mar 08 04:19 PM

Thanks, Philip and ganesh77.

Now I get it.

But isn't it more reasonable to say "The city plans to put up a wall around the entire city with a gate to make it more closed in and private?"

  
ganesh77  #489261  Sat, 15 Mar 08 04:27 PM
Angliholic, I agree with what you say.
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service