About "here"

   Share on Facebook  
hurricane  #26360  Fri, 26 Mar 04 09:02 PM
Could anyone please explain the usuage of "here"?
for example:
Is anybody here?
Is anybody in here?
What's the difference? thanks!
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sun, Mar 21 2004
New Member (11)
suzi  #26397  Sat, 27 Mar 04 02:22 PM
you might use them in slightly different contexts -
I imagine using 1. whena rriving at a social funtion of some sort, maybe as I enter the hallway, "here" being more generlised.

the other one - I'd use outside a room, just before opening the door to have a look "in" the specific space
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Jan 7 2004
Full Member (465)
Proficient Speaker
rommie  #26401  Sat, 27 Mar 04 03:02 PM
I'm not sure about that, Suzi. Outside a room, just before opening the door to have a look, I might say "Is anybody in there?", But not "here" - "here" is too immediate. It can only really mean "at the location of the speaker".

The only difference I can think of is that "in here" defines the boundaries of "here" more precisely. It suggests that you are enclosed (in a room, for example), and you are asking if anybody else is in that room. On the other hand, "Is there anybody here" (without the "in") could be used outdoors - or it could be used indoors when when the "here" in question isn't just one room. For example, a coach at a sports club might ask "Is anybody here yet?", meaning "Has anyone arrived (in the building, not necessarily in the room) yet?"

There's very little in it though. "Here" is where you (the speaker) are. Whether or not you can use "in" (or "on", or "under", or any other preposition in fact) is really only a matter of whether or not it makes sense to do that, and whether or not there would be any point.

Rommie
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 26 2004
Earth orbit
Regular Member (606)
hurricane  #26422  Sat, 27 Mar 04 08:12 PM
I thought "in here" was wrong before, but later I saw it from time to time.
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service