Click here to play

adjective phrase

   Share on Facebook  
Iglika  #193638  Tue, 07 Feb 06 09:57 AM
dear teachers,can you help me please!Can you mark the head,the modifier,the specifier,the determiner and the complement in the following APs:
a new history of Korea which has just been published
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Feb 7 2006
New Member (07)
Click here to play!
paco2004  #193697  Tue, 07 Feb 06 12:09 PM
Hello Iglika

Here we have good English teachers. But I don’t think anyone here is acquainted with Chomsky's generative grammar theories well enough to answer your question. So I recommend you to study yourself and try to find the answers yourself by reading the articles in  U-Penn Linguistics.

paco
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Nov 17 2004
Senior Member (4,095)
In Japan today even dogs are learning how to bow-wow in English.
goldmund  #193734  Tue, 07 Feb 06 01:52 PM

Dear Iglika and Paco,

I do not know the theory of Chomsky. But it is perhaps:-

«a» determiner

«new» modifier

«history» head

«of Korea» specifier

«which has just been published» complement

But it is only guesswork. Smile [:)]

Kind regards, Smile [:)]

Goldmund

  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Fri, Jun 10 2005
Regular Member (581)
«Tout homme peut dire véritablement; mais dire ordonnément, prudemment et suffisamment, peu d'hommes le peuvent.» - Michel de Montaigne
Iglika  #193863  Tue, 07 Feb 06 09:18 PM
Dear paco, thank you for your advice I don't like Chomsky but my teacher does  Smile [:)]  

Best wishes
Iglika

P.S. goldmund, I'll tell you if you are right after reading the U-Penn Linguistics
  
milky  #193932  Wed, 08 Feb 06 01:12 AM
 Goldmund wrote:

Dear Iglika and Paco,

I do not know the theory of Chomsky. But it is perhaps:-

«a» determiner

«new» modifier

«history» head

«of Korea» specifier

«which has just been published» complement

I'd agree with that.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 15 2004
Senior Member (3,149)
Hume said that if we had perfect or complete descriptive knowledge of reality, we could not, by reasoning, derive a single valid "ought".
paco2004  #193966  Wed, 08 Feb 06 02:38 AM
(a^(new^((history)^(of Korea)))

history=Head in NP
of Korea=Complement (PP) or AjP (Spec)?
     They storied Korea. --> "of Korea" is a Complement(=PP).
     Koreans storied. --> "of Korea" is a Spec to history.
new=AjP= Spec to ((history)^(of Korea))
a =DP=Spec to (new^((history)^(of Korea))

As for (which …), I cannot get what is it. My guess is rather:
a^((which..)^(new H of K))  --> Spec(AjP) to (new H of K)

"Modifiers" is not a Chomskian term.

paco
  
Iglika  #194288  Wed, 08 Feb 06 07:45 PM
thank you very much paco-
I thought the same, but yesterday I forgot "hardback" -a new hardback history of Korea which has just been published .I think which....is an adjective clause and "just published" is another AP-"just" is specifier and published is a Head .In my opinion "hardback" is a modifier...... I'm not sure..........
  
paco2004  #194327  Wed, 08 Feb 06 09:27 PM

Hello Iglika

I'm sorry I could not give you definite answers. Frankly speaking, I myself do not know much about generative grammar. But please remind there is a possibility your teacher uses grammatical terms in his/her own way. As far as I know, "modifier" is a term used by traditional grammarians. On the other hand "specifier" is a term used by Chomskians. "Head" is also a term used by Chomskians in constituent analyses, but some traditional grammarians use it to mean a core noun in a noun phrase. So I think your teacher might teach you his/her own theory of English grammar, mixing Chomsky's theory and traditional grammar theories.

paco

  
Iglika  #196190  Mon, 13 Feb 06 06:41 AM
THANK YOU,DEAR PACO!!!
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions