Affect, effect

1 2 3 4
   Share on Facebook  
Guest  #30455  Thu, 20 May 04 04:48 PM
Hi folks,

I really love this site, it reminds me of the apostrophe protection society blog. Very interesting!

Anyway, I believe there is a very simple method to differentiate between effect and affect.

When used as nouns, the difference is pretty obvious.
An effect is a result of an action, while an affect is a feeling or emotion.

When used as verbs:
Effect is an active verb: 'The government effected swift decreases in the unemployment level.'
Affect is a passive verb: 'The unemployment level was positively affected by new government policies.'

If you have any trouble figuring out the difference between the active and passive tense, the trick is the word by. Usually, if there is a clause at the end of a sentence starting with by, the verb is passive. In the first sentence, the subject (government) is the actor. In other words the subject carried out an action. In the second sentence, the subject (unemployment level) is acted upon by a different entity.

However, affect can also be used in an active sense, but the context is different, ‘Mike affected an English accent to disguise his Irish roots’.

This of course is only my humble opinion, put together in the days before Google. So, I’d like to hear any comments on my theory, good or bad. If any of my sweeping grammatical statements are incorrect, I’ll have to shift the blame onto my English teacher of yore.

Cheerio!
  
miriam  #30461  Thu, 20 May 04 05:06 PM
Quote
"Sorry, you're wrong, the sentence is correct as is. Motor function and gait are AFFECTED by CP."

"affect" is a verb, "effect" a noun.

Motor function and gait are AFFECTED by cerebral palsy.
Cerebral palsy has a certain EFFECT on motor function and gait.

The opriginal sentence should read:
I have enclosed portions of a chapter from Baker's Textbook of Clinical Neurology, which I believe you will find of significance in discussing the origins of cerebral palsy and its EFFECT on motor function and gait.

Miriam

  
Top 100 Contributor
Joined on Mon, May 10 2004
Argentina
Regular Member (821)
Teachers
"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something." Plato
Guest  #83302  Wed, 23 Mar 05 05:37 PM
Could you please tell if this is correct, please.

'A lot of symptoms that one person has won't affect some one else'

I'm starting to get a grasp of the difference, but this example has got me.

Thanks in advance!
  
CalifJim  #83420  Thu, 24 Mar 05 04:35 AM
It is a verb meaning "have an effect on", so it has to be the verb "affect".

It occurs without "the" or "an" or "no" (or other determiners), so that's another clue that it's probably not the noun "effect", meaning something like "result".

That drug can have a very powerful ________ (affect=have an effect on?, effect?) on the nervous system.

Nothing you say can _________ (affect=have an effect on?, effect?) my decision.

That joke did not have the intended ________ . (affect=have an effect on?, effect?)

The stroke he had years ago still continues to _________ (affect=have an effect on?, effect?) his speech.

(Answers: effect, affect, effect, affect)

Geeked [8-|]

You've heard of "causes" and "effects"? Well, strangely enough "effect" is almost never a verb unless it means "cause"! And that happens very rarely.
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (17,477)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Guest  #107355  Fri, 10 Jun 05 04:32 PM
i still don't get it i guess....

why don't these two sentences use the same word in question?

--Mike affected an English accent to disguise his Irish roots.
--When the government effected tax cuts, everyone received a larger paycheck.

it seems that they are both used as a verb, meaning to accomplish/bring about.
  
Guest  #107369  Fri, 10 Jun 05 05:19 PM
another one for you experts out there:

What is the effect of temperature on the wood?

(a) "The wood is affected by temperature...."
---OR---
(b) "The wood is effected by temperature...."
  
Anonymous  #155103  Fri, 04 Nov 05 12:42 PM
"Nothing you say can _________ (affect=have an effect on?, effect?) my decision."

actually, this one's a tricky one. technically, you can use either word here without affecting the outcome of the sentence. the only difference is between the active and the passive voice of the action. using 'effect' in this case would be using it in the sense of 'change', which is active. it's also a very peculiar way to say it though, so affect is probably the clearer option to go for.

and, just to be exacting, the word to use in the original question is definitely 'affect' because we're not talking about a psychological emotional change - it's a physical change, and therefore requires the use of the verb, and not the noun.
  
goldmund  #155115  Fri, 04 Nov 05 01:55 PM

Dear sir,

«Nothing you say can affect my decision.» It means that nothing you say can influence the decision.

«Nothing you say can effect my decision.» It means that nothing you say can make the decision happen.

The second example is unusual, I think. Smile [:)]

Kind regards, Smile [:)]

Goldmund

  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Fri, Jun 10 2005
Regular Member (581)
«Tout homme peut dire véritablement; mais dire ordonnément, prudemment et suffisamment, peu d'hommes le peuvent.» - Michel de Montaigne
Anonymous  #319463  Wed, 24 Jan 07 08:55 PM

What would be correct for this sentence?

During the hospitalization, the patient's (affect, effect) became more appropriate.

HELP!!

  
1 2 3 4
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service