Can't have p.p. vs. couldn't have p.p.

   Share on Facebook  
komountain  #55317  Sun, 14 Nov 04 09:06 PM
For me, a little bit of blurriness persists between the two.
Can anybody draw a clean-cut line between them? Pleeeese help.

(1)He can't have seen the movie.
(2)He couldn't have seen the movie.

(3)He can't have seen the movie last month.
(4)He couldn't have seen the movie last month.

(5)He can't have arrived by now.
(6)He couldn't have arrived by now.

Which of the pair would you native speakers use?
  
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 8 2004
Full Member (269)
CalifJim  #55334  Sun, 14 Nov 04 10:51 PM
I think I say "couldn't" in this context more often than "can't". The two are virtually identical; however, "can't" is more objective and concerned with the laws of logic, I would say.

"He can't have seen the movie" sounds like a detective's remark, a logical deduction from other evidence in the case, and so does "He must not have seen the movie", another equivalent!Smile [:)] .

"He couldn't have seen the movie" sounds more everyday, and slightly more tentative (or conditional?) in view of the fact that "couldn't have" can mean "wouldn't have been able to". "would be" is always more tentative than "is".

That said, you will hear all of these in various contexts. They all say that it is not possible that he has seen the movie, or that the only logical conclusion from the evidence is that he has not seen the movie, which amounts to practically the same thing.

Your other pairs of sentences can certainly be analyzed in the same way.

Geeked [8-|]
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (17,566)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
komountain  #55368  Mon, 15 Nov 04 03:39 AM
Than you.

Is it okay if I understand the phrase "last month" in (3) and (4) has nothing to do with the choice between "can't" and "couldn't"?

I cite one question from an ESL website. No situation was provided. Just a truncated sentence was.

"I ___ have read it last year."

a. mayn't
b. couldn't
c. can't

They say the answer is b. Can I just write this question off as weird?
If b is a correct answer, what's the logic behind this?
I don't have any intention to put you on the spot. I stand on your side.
  
CalifJim  #55375  Mon, 15 Nov 04 04:14 AM
No, it's not just weird. I imagine that most speakers feel "could" is more appropriate than "can" in sentences which refer to the past explicitly, as in "last year". Personally, I think c. is a possible answer as well, but as I said, it gives the impression of emphasizing the logic of the situation. "I can't have read it last year. It wasn't even written until last month!"

For test-taking purposes, "couldn't" certainly could be considered a "better" answer without being the "only" answer.

Please understand that others could have a different approach to your question!

Smile [:)]
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service