Challenge .....(Long one)

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
FluidnMotion  #281735  Mon, 16 Oct 06 04:36 PM

Peter, Paul and Anthony are honest fishermen. They went out to the ocean to catch fish on a small boat.They had a good catch. By the time they returned, it was nighfall. It is an old fisherman's saying "never split your fish after sunset". So, they decide to wait till daybreak.They make small tents with palm leaves for each of them and go to sleep in them.

It's next day morning.

Peter gets up at 5:30am and sees the sun rising but does not see the others out of their tents. Not wanting disturb their sleep, he goes to the catch and counts the number of fish they had caught the previous day.The count is not exactly divisible by 3.  To divide equally and avoid confusion, he has to throw one fish back into the ocean. Like a gentleman he does that, he takes one-third and leaves.

Paul gets up at 6:00am and sees it is morning but does not see the others out of their tents (Yes, Peter left his empty tent standing). Assuming no one has got up from their sleep, he goes to the catch and counts the number of fish they had caught the previous day.The count is not exactly divisible by 3. To divide equally and avoid confusion, he has to throw one fish back into the ocean. Like a gentleman he does that, he takes one-third and leaves.

Anthony gets up at 6:30am and sees it is morning but does not see the others out of their tents (Yes, Peter and Paul have left their empty tents standing). Assuming no one has got up from their sleep, he too goes to the catch and counts the number of fish they had caught the previous day. The count is not exactly divisible by 3. To divide equally and avoid confusion, he has to throw one fish back into the ocean. Like a gentleman he does that, he takes one-third and leaves.

Now, the questions.

1. What is the smallest possible number of fish they could have caught so that, this mathematical calculation by all three fishermen is possible?

2. What is the remainder after Peter, Paul and Anthony have taken their "One-thirds"?

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Sep 19 2006
Michigan, United States
Full Member (149)
So it is written, So it shall be done!
Eargasms  #281898  Tue, 17 Oct 06 12:12 AM

1   I reckon the total  number of fish is 79  ( First man thows one back to leave 78 divide by 3 = 26.  Take 26 from 78 to leave 52.  Second man throws one back to leave 51 divide by 3 = 17. Take 17 from 51 leaves 34. Third man throws one gack to leave 33 divide by 3= 11)

2 So the remaining fish is 22   ( 33 - 11)

  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Sun, Feb 13 2005
Full Member (424)
FluidnMotion  #282145  Tue, 17 Oct 06 02:25 PM

Eargasms, Good!

But you can better that answer.

  
benita  #282176  Tue, 17 Oct 06 03:22 PM

Would the lowest remainder of fish be two?  (I don't claim to be good at math)

The total catch be forty?

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 31 2005
India
Contributing Member (1,667)
But I have promises to keep, and miles to go before I sleep, and miles to go before I sleep - Robert Frost
FluidnMotion  #282191  Tue, 17 Oct 06 04:01 PM

No Benita.

Starting with 40....throw away 1, becomes 39

1/3rd taken, leaves 26 behind,

throw away 1, becomes 25 (and still not divisible by 3).

  
benita  #282216  Tue, 17 Oct 06 04:28 PM

giggle giggle - I know!  Big Smile [:D] (Do you really think I'm that bad at math??) 

You would make a good professor - but ........what would be your subject??

By the way - this mathematical riddle/puzzle has a proper set of equations.  Why don't we just let others answer. Wink [;)]

  
Eargasms  #282404  Tue, 17 Oct 06 11:33 PM

Hi FluidnMotion

 Here's my latest effort......................

  Start with 52 throw one away 51

1/3rd taken leaves 34  throw one away 33

1/3rd taken leaves 22 throw one away 21

1/3rd taken away leaves 14          Smile [:)]

  
FluidnMotion  #282662  Wed, 18 Oct 06 02:22 PM

Hello Eargasms,

You are there, but still you can beat it.

  
Eargasms  #282821  Wed, 18 Oct 06 11:17 PM

Ok  Third time lucky then ...........................   Big Smile [:D]

 Start with 25 throw one away 24

1/3rd taken leaves 16  throw one away 15

1/3rd taken leaves 10  throw one away  9

1/3rd taken away leaves  6

 I think i got there in the end ! lol

  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: Puzzles, Riddles, and Word ESL Games
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service