Forums · General English Grammar & Vocabulary, Listening & Speaking · General English Grammar Questions
Guest:I am trying to find a worksheet or just some examples that will demonstrate to my students when they should put a comma before the word "because", and why in most instances there isn't a comma before "because".
http://www.unc.edu/depts/wcweb/handouts/commas.html"]COMMAS[/url], and if you google the word, you'll find a lot of sites with more information and examples.
'Because' normally introduces a dependent clause, and dependent clauses are normally restrictive, hence taking no comma. When sentences and their clauses get too long, however, a comma may be necessary for clarity.
Hope this helps.
I came across the following example on the internet, which neatly demonstrates why you often need to think about the contents of your statement before you decide:
I knew that President Nixon would resign that morning because my sister worked in the White House and she called me with the news.
Without the comma, the sentence might suggest that President Nixon resigned because my sister worked in the White House.
On the other hand, we must assume at least a little intelligence and common sense in the reader.
No reasonable person would ever think Nixon was going to resign because someone's sister worked in the White House, for heaven's sake!
(Nevertheless, I do agree that the comma helps in this case.)
Anonymous:Maybe you should find a worksheet or some examples that will demonstrate that you should always include commas and periods inside quotation marks.
Anonymous:Your comment "you often need to think about the contents of your statement" is VERY accurate, and your internet resource has given an excellent example of who people don't think about the contents. The resource has considered the wrong aspect of this sentence. It's these inappropriate examples that cause so much confusion when punctuating. The consideration here is the 'subject' of the sentence.
The reason a comma is not used before "because" is because the subject of this sentence is "I knew", not "President Nixon would resign that morning"
To explain ...
What this sentence is really saying is I knew that 'insert information' because my sister worked in the White House, and she called me with the news. You can clearly see in this case that you would not place a comma before "because." However, in both cases there should be a comma after house as she called me with the news is an independent clause.
The very use of "because" dictates that the following clause will be sub-ordinated in every case, and sub-ordinated clauses are not separated by commas.
I hope I have explained this well enough to clarify your confusion. In short, never use a comma before because*.
*Disclaimer unless the writer is being 'creative' and knows the rules he/she is breaking
Anonymous:The worksheets you should be looking for are ones dealing with 'Subordinating Conjunctions' ('because' is a subordinating conjunctions)
Anonymous:I'm sure your intended recipient is delighted to be assisted in such a charming and generous manner. To the point, one shouldn't 'always include commas and periods inside quotation marks'. That only applies to American English. British English, for one, places punctuation outside the quotation marks (single in the first instance and often called inverted commas or speech marks) unless the punctuation applies to the quoted material.
Anonymous:wow that nixon thing, it's a GRRREAATTT sentence, it really helped me understand!!! thx [y]
People are waiting to help.
Live chatRegistered users can join here
Related forum topics:
Comma before/with 'but'?comma before 'and'?Do I need a comma before IS?Comma before the word 'with'?comma before because?comma before 'although?comma or not?a comma?when to put a comma before so?comma before 'when'?comma before 'so that'?Comma before quote?Question about comma before an AND?Comma before but/and in THAT sentence...Comma before "if"?Comma before Adjective?Comma before it is?Why no comma, just before "the size of"s?