Forums · General English Grammar & Vocabulary, Listening & Speaking · General English Grammar Questions
Is this correct?
Not the biggest boy in the world, either, at 5ft 2ins, he began working out...
Of all the marks of punctuation the comma offers the most difficulty in use and the widest range for individual choice. Though often marking rhetorical or elocutionary pauses, the comma is used primarily to separate or to set off in a group. It sometimes distinguishes nonrestrictive modifiers from restrictive modifiers.More to the example at hand, they say:
Commas set off transitional words and expressions (as on the contrary, on the other hand, consequently, furthermore, moreover, nevertheless, therefore) whenever they are or would be spoken with the adjacent rising or sustained pauses that indicate subordinate matter <The question, however, remains unsettled.> <Nevertheless, we shall go.> <On the contrary, under the rules a vote is in order.>I would say use a comma before either if you feel there would be a pause there if the sentence were spoken.
Either in this sentence is used as an adverb and means likewise or also. It is used as an intensifier following the initial negative phrase. There would have to have been a previous statement to justify either. Also, I think the word being is ellipted.
He was left weak by childhood illnesses. [Being] not the biggest boy in the world[,] either, at five feet two inches, he began working out.To me, the use of the first comma is debatable. In this construction I would tend to omit it because either seems to belong with the rest of the negative phrase. Again from Webster's:
<You'll not go far in life and you won't be happy either. --W. J. Reilly>.
Is there a way of working out when to and when not?
I get hung up when to use commas with either at the end of a sentence...
No, I can't either.
No, I don't either.
I don't go mountain climbing and I don't go mountain walking, either.
I don't like peaches or nectarines, either.
You'll not go far in life and you won't be happy either.
Not the biggest heavyweight in the world, either.
Note the commas after some 'eithers' and not with others
Here is all of the statement on this usage in Webster's Third New International Dictionary.
4 either adv 1: at all : LIKEWISE, MOREOVER --- used for emphasis after a negative <they are the best available and are not expensive either> esp. one contradicting a previous affirmation <it's raining. It isn't either> or agreeing with a previous negative statement <I didn't see it. Nor I either> or supplementing one <you'll not go far in life and you won't be happy either -- W. J. Reilly>
Anonymous:um...no, either is never and can never be a pronoun. everything else you say makes sense, though.
Anonymous:Either can be an indenfinite pronoun — along with such as words as "all" and "none."
People are waiting to help.
Live chatRegistered users can join here
Related forum topics:
Usage of a comma before 'and' (Guest: Tharabg)?Comma before/with 'but'?Comma before because?Before Greek?comma before 'and'?Do I need a comma before IS?Comma before the adverb?Comma before the word 'with'?comma before unless?comma before 'although?comma or not?Use comma before 'and/or' or not?when to put a comma before so?comma before 'so that'?Comma before the word "and"?Comma before quote?A comma or no comma?Comma before but/and in THAT sentence...Comma before "if"?