Click here to play

comma, finally

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #299275  Thu, 30 Nov 06 04:37 PM
Do I need a comma after the word "finally?"

My dog ate the rug, ran away, got lost, and finally came home.

Is "finally" an introductory word even though it is used at the end of the sentence?

Thanks
  
Click here to play!
Tidus  #299289  Thu, 30 Nov 06 05:45 PM

It reads fine to me without the comma, but you can put one in if you want.

How do you know that your dog got lost?  It might have been happy wandering around for a while, but knew its way home. Smile [:)]

  
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 27 2006
England
Full Member (360)
TommyT  #299513  Fri, 01 Dec 06 11:23 AM
Perhaps you may put commas around finally if you want to emphasise that your dog has FINALLY come home.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Fri, Dec 1 2006
New Member (14)
Dejanm83  #299529  Fri, 01 Dec 06 12:20 PM

I think there's a difference in meaning.

If you put the comma behind finally, you're simply listing the things which the dog did, and coming home is the last (final) one of those things. (And that is, I believe, the intended meaning)
My dog ate the rug, ran away, got lost, and finally, came home.

If you say
My dog ate the rug, ran away, got lost, and finally came home.
you're saying that you waited in anticipation for the dog to do all these things before it eventually came home.

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Fri, Nov 17 2006
Bosnia and Herzegowina
New Member (16)
Marius Hancu  #299553  Fri, 01 Dec 06 01:24 PM
 Dejanm83 wrote:

I think there's a difference in meaning.

If you put the comma behind finally, you're simply listing the things which the dog did, and coming home is the last (final) one of those things. (And that is, I believe, the intended meaning)
My dog ate the rug, ran away, got lost, and finally, came home.

If you say
My dog ate the rug, ran away, got lost, and finally came home.
you're saying that you waited in anticipation for the dog to do all these things before it eventually came home.

I think you're right, but one needs a comma after and in the first case. See such a listing in the New York Times:
--------

Article available with TimesSelect subscription or for purchase METROPOLITAN DIARY

... handkerchiefs, coins and, finally, a real live white rabbit ...

November 13, 2006 - (NYT) - New York and Region - News -
---------

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Apr 26 2006
Montreal, Canada
Veteran Member (11,673)
Proficient Speaker
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions