Could of vs could have

   Share on Facebook  
Erbilicious  #303181  Tue, 12 Dec 06 05:42 PM

i am attempting to explain the difference between could of and could have and really don't know if i am explaining it correctly or not.

My example is: I could of picked up the praying mantis to observe it, but that might of hurt the mantis.

I believe that is incorrect and corrected I have: I could have picked up the praying mantic to observe it, but that might have hurt the mantis.

Could someone check this and make sure I am doing this correctly?  Any explanation would be greatly appreciated!!!

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Sep 5 2006
New Member (05)
nona the brit  #303184  Tue, 12 Dec 06 05:55 PM

You are correct.

'of' is sometimes used in error in the place of 'have'. Presumably because in speech 'have' is often slurred/shortened to 've', which sounds more like 'of'.

Could of, would of, should of are always incorrect.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Sep 22 2004
England
Veteran Member (11,502)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
The name says it all.
Zerox  #303185  Tue, 12 Dec 06 05:55 PM

"Could of" is wrong, it does not exist. It is, however, easy to mix up "could have" and "could of", since it is normally pronounced  in a slurred way and then it sounds like "could of".

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Wed, May 10 2006
Full Member (267)
-It is rational that the irrational contradicts with the rational-
Erbilicious  #303223  Tue, 12 Dec 06 09:36 PM
thanks a million...  just wanted to check and make sure I was on the right track... 
  
Anonymous  #303402  Wed, 13 Dec 06 12:46 PM
 Zerox wrote:
"Could of" ... does not exist.


I suppose that has some paradoxical value.

/km
  
Zerox  #303432  Wed, 13 Dec 06 02:55 PM

 Anonymous wrote:
 Zerox wrote:
"Could of" ... does not exist.


I suppose that has some paradoxical value.

/km

Well, of course.

  
Anonymous  #553150  Sun, 10 Aug 08 10:51 AM
of ... is a preposition and is generally placed before a noun
eg.  she is part OF a group.  ( a group. the noun preceded by it's preposition)

could ... is an adverb which describes the verb
eg. she COULD be part OF the group ... (COULD describes the verb TO BE)

It follows from the above that the expression:

 COULD OF has no sensible grammatical meaning.... (ie. an ADVERB describing a PREPOSITION)

COULD HAVE is an adverb describing the verb (HAVE) which follows it; this has a sensible grammatical meaning.
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service