1 2

countable uncountable?

This question has no verified answers · 11 replies
I've looked up most of the dictionaries online but I couldn't find an explanation. All the dictionaries say the "PIE" can be countable and uncountable. When is it countable, when uncountable?
New Member 25
And by the way do you know a web site where I can find more information and explanations on nouns which are both count. and uncount. Thanks..
New Member 25
It is uncountable when you think of it as a boundaryless substance.
It is countable when you think of it as an object with boundaries.

Do you want some pie? (Do you want some meat? Do you want some butter?)
I baked three pies. (I baked three cakes. I washed three plates.)


CJ
California
Veteran Member 39,240
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche

And by the way do you know a web site where I canfind more information and explanations on nouns which are both count.and uncount. Thanks..

shows which nouns are U/C and has good examples.
Veteran Member 11,673
I couldn't understand what you mean by "boundryless substance" Isn't there a simpler explanation???smile
New Member 25
Thank you Marius I'll check it
New Member 25
I couldn't understand what you mean by "boundrylesssubstance" Isn't there a simpler explanation???smile[/quote]

large (flat) cake: I want some cake (usually, cut from the large one)
small cakes (prepared/cooked separately): I want some cakes

http://members.nuvox.net/~zt.proicer/cakepict/FOOTBALL.htm
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kjdm/294302363/
Veteran Member 11,673
NOW I get it..... Thank you
New Member 25
I couldn't understand what you mean by "boundryless substance" Isn't there a simpler explanation???smile[/quote]

Well.. CJ I think he's right. Beginners may misinterpret the word "boundaryless". Baoundaryless can be interpreted as something which is too big to be measured.

Jaso, you can say it like "when the boundary is not identified". It's almost the same but rather explixit.

GB
PAKISTAN
Full Member 450
The best way to learn is to learn from your mistakes.
More