Hi,
1. Attentively, he looks at each picture in the
huge photo album to search for a familiar face that he can vaguely remember.
2. Attentively, he looks at each picture in the huge photo album searching for
a familiar face that he can vaguely remember.
You wrote, “I wouldn't disagree with your
suggestion that the second example here is better than the first. To me,
'searching' suggests a single activity that continues while perhaps hundreds of
photos are looked at. On the other hand, 'to search' suggests a series of
discrete activities that start/stop as each photo is looked at. The 'searching'
activity with a long and single duration is obviously more intense.” That is
also an instruction that we received from our teacher. Stretch was his keyword.
Now, regarding the two sentences you asked me to give some thought:
He ran as fast as he could, to try to win a gold
medal.
He ran as fast as he could, trying to win a gold
medal.
First, I think the comma weakens the entire
sentence too drastically. We should remove the comma. Even without the comma, I still think the first one is better
because the emotion is not strong in the main clause. Rule #1, “To unleash the
power of verb chose infinitive over gerund and noun phrases,” should be applied
to add weight to the entire sentence.
However, let’s use “to try to win” and “trying to
win” in the two following sentences:
With the loving father’s
image in his heart, John relentlessly pushes his body to the limit to try to win
a gold medal.
With the loving father’s
image in his heart, John relentlessly pushes his body to the limit trying to win
a gold medal.
What do you think? To me, the second sentence is better using
rule #2, “soften the verb by using gerund to stretch a longing / yearning emotion.” In
fact, the first one does not even flow well; somehow, its rhythm changes too
sharply and abruptly when ‘to try to win’ arrives.
That said, I think you are right to suggest that we should
use the word guideline instead of rule - a guideline with a merit though.
Thank you very much for spending your time discussing this
with me. For me, it has been a good educational exercise and a great pleasure!
Hoa Thai