creams and detergents

1 2 3
   Share on Facebook  
Mister Micawber  #532161  Wed, 25 Jun 08 05:47 AM
.
What I offered you was some reasonably reputable on-line examples of creams as a countable noun, Goodman, to support -- obviously -- my own belief that it is perfectly acceptable.  What I would like is to see some sort of support for your viewpoint.

Ms Google gives us:

3,770 for "a lot of creams"
1 for "a lot of cream products"
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Aug 4 2004
Yokohama
Veteran Member (21,226)
SystemAdministratorTeachers
'The question is,' said Humpty Dumpty, 'which is to be master-- that's all.'
Yoong Liat  #532169  Wed, 25 Jun 08 06:30 AM

'Cream' is an uncountable noun according to Collins Cobuild English Dictionary for Advanced Learners and Times-Chambers Essential English Dictionary.

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Sep 4 2006
Singapore
Veteran Member (6,010)
Yoong Liat
Mister Micawber  #532172  Wed, 25 Jun 08 06:39 AM
.
Cream is countable or uncountable according to the on-line Cambridge:

4 [C or U] a soft substance that you rub into your skin

Now, stop wasting my time.
  
Goodman  #532453  Wed, 25 Jun 08 05:19 PM

 

Mr. Miclawer,

I wasn’t going to expand this pluralization discussion on “creams” and “wines”.
But it really bothered the heck out of me for two reasons.
1) I really wanted to find out if I was really blowing hot air on this subject
because of my misunderstanding of this topic, and 2) if there is another side of the usage
I am not aware of. 
This is perhaps not relevant to the discussion but to establish my point,  I think it needs
to be said. Mrs. Milton whom I learned English from was an excellent English teacher who
 also had taught for 5 years at the
Beijing University, which is a top University in China, by
invitation of the Government.  Many of her students had landed positions working for the
Chinese Government and the U.N. as translators and interpreters. I was very blessed to be
among her students. Most of my English foundation was learned from her.  And I was really
surprised to see your examples pluralizing “cream” and “wine”. By your earlier examples, which I
compared with the information found on the
WEB, I must ask this question. Am I to understand
that it’s completely grammatical to say in a restaurant “may I have 2 waters and soups?”.  I know
we hear that all the time but if we are discussing the whether a particular usage is grammatically
correct, running into this  type of scenario is inevitable.  Here are some “supports” you had
asked for which may not may not be validated to your satisfaction. No doubt, you are the
English authority and perhaps possess “superiority” over many frequented this forum and I don’t
mean to sound like challenging  your examples, let alone to waste anymore of your time. 
Nonetheless, as a serious learner, I’d owe the real answers to myself and the learners  if I just
accepted your answers as given.  I may be wrong with my search result and you are correct.
And If so,  here is my “advanced apology”.

 

 

 

 Nouns only countable nouns can be either singular or plural. ... He had some ice cream on
his face. He had an ice
cream. mass. countable ...
www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/tta/wc/nouns.htm - 21k - Cached - Similar pages

http://ajaja.paradoxinc.org/Basic/Grammar/CountAndNoncount.ht 
Liquids: beer, milk, coffee, blood, cream, juice, honey, gasoline, oil, shampoo, soup, tea, water, wine.
Solids and semi-solids: Bread, butter, cheese, ice, ice cream, lettuce, toast, meat, beef, chicken, fish, ham, lamb, pork, chalk, 
copper, cotton, glass, gold, iron, , soap, tin, toothpaste, wood, wool,
http://leo.stcloudstate.edu/grammar/countnon.html
A Revision of the RulesThe exceptions require that the rule for pluralizing be revised: count nouns and nouns used 
in a count sense can be pluralized; noncount nouns and nouns used in a noncount sense cannot.

 

Pluralizes with -s

Does not Pluralize

Count Noun

X

 

Count Use

X

 

Noncount Noun

 

X

Noncount Use

 

X


 
 

http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080425090142AAom2ui

Answers (4)

If coffee is an uncountable noun, cream certainly is by common sense. Thus the rule applies.

·         Answerer 1

Many nouns can be used as countables or uncountables. It depends on whether you are thinking of a substance or
a single serving or object made of the substance. So:

Beer is fattening (uncountable - the substance)
Don't drink more than three beers a day. (Countable - servings)

I love chocolate (uncountable - the substance)
Get me a box of chocolates (countable - individual pieces)

A vase made of blown glass (uncountable - the substance)
A glass of wine (A single piece / artifact)

Coffee gives me indigestion (the substance - uncountable)
I need at least three coffees to wake up on a morning (countable - individual servings)

    • 2 months ago

 

http://www3.law.cuny.edu/wc/students/multilingual/articles.html

Uncountable nouns often refer to drinks and food, other general substances, or concepts (meat, tea, steel, information, justice):

Examples of Uncountable Nouns in English:

  1. Food and Drink: bacon, beef, beer, bread, butter, cabbage, candy, cauliflower, chicken, chocolate, coffee, corn,
    cream
    , fish, fruit, juice, lettuce, meat, milk, oil, pasta, rice, salt, spinach, sugar, tea, water, whiskey, wine, yogurt.
  2. General Substances: air,cement, clay, coal, copper, dirt, dust, foam, gasoline, gold, ice, leather, paper, petroleum,
    plastic, rain, rubber, silver, soap, steel, wood, wool.
  3. Abstract nouns: abandonment, access, adultery, advice, alimony, anger, anguish, arson, authentication, beauty, capacity,
    conduct, confidence, courage, deprivation, desperation, discretion, employment, empowerment, evidence, extortion, fortune,
     fun, happiness, health, honesty, housing, information, insurance, intelligence, intent, knowledge, land, love, malice, negligence,
    poverty, privacy, real estate, sadness, satisfaction, strength, truth, wealth.
  4. Others: biology, clothing, darkness, equipment, furniture, gossip, homework, jewelry, luggage, machinery, mail, money, music,
    news, poetry, pollution, research, scenery, traffic, transportation, violence, weather, weight, work.

Some uncountable nouns (except for concepts) can be turned into countable nouns by preposing a phrase to them
(two bottles of wine, a bar of soap, a piece of information, an act of violence, a burst of anger, a piece of evidence).

e.g.
The defendant's lawyer is sure the judge will accept new evidence in this case.

vs.
The defendant's lawyer is sure the judge will accept three new pieces of evidence in this case.

Some uncountable nouns can be used in the plural, but their meaning changes:

experience / experiences: e.g.,
He had to rely on experience / I lived unforgettable experiences
  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 7 2005
Calif. USA
Senior Member (3,200)
The name says it all!
Kooyeen  #532561  Wed, 25 Jun 08 09:20 PM
I'd say I agree with MrM. My dictionary (Longman) lists those words saying [C or U], which means they can be treated as countable or uncountable nouns, generally speaking. Anyway, even for the uncountable words it doesn't explicitly list as countable too, I think we can say uncountable nouns can often be "categorized" and used with an article. I can't be sure, but I'd say a sentence like this is ok, for example: I've never heard an English like that. = I've never heard a kind of English like that.
By the way, another reason why certain uncountable nouns are often used as countable nouns might be that lots of commercial products are sold in its own container, and uncountable product + container = countable product. A soda. A cream. But this doesn't seem to work for every product, I'm afraid.
Just my opinion. Smile

EDIT: I just read Goodman's post, and I started to think of "waters" to mean two "portions" of water, two bottles, whatever. It seems reasonable, if you think of beers and sodas, but that's exactly the kind of thing I'm not sure about yet. So I searched the net and... I was so lucky! Look, GG says "two waters" at the restaurant, so I guess it's ok to treat it as countable in that context, like other uncountable things.
http://www.englishforums.com/English/SoupEating/clhqn/post.htm
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Senior Member (3,973)
Moderator
If you don't have a sense of humor already, it's about time you buy one.
New2grammar  #532564  Wed, 25 Jun 08 09:41 PM
I think there's no right and wrong. It depends on whether the uncountable is used as a countable noun by native speakers. I know Americans count waters (bottled water), coffees (different kinds or multiple cups), toothpaste (context dependent). So I agree with Kooyen that logically, most uncountables can be used as countables. Regarding being natural, that depends on whether natives use them and I believe it's regional too. If an uncountalbe is not accepted today, it may be acceptable in the future when somebody, maybe a celebrity, starts using it and the usage spreads. Nothing is impossible Stick out tongue Just my humble opinion.


  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Nov 21 2006
Veteran Member (7,670)
Who wants to go sailing around the world with me?
Mister Micawber  #532581  Wed, 25 Jun 08 10:59 PM
Hello, Goodman,

I'm sorry that I cannot read all of your post because of the various formatting, but what I can read of it seems accurate. To encapsulate the 'correct' guidelines:

May I have 2 waters and soups?”. I know we hear that all the time but if we are discussing the whether a particular usage is grammatically correct

You have answered your own question-- we hear it all the time, so it is grammatically correct.  How else could we accept 'Everyone please hand in their papers' ?

The revision that you list seems precisely correct (if I may insert a word that I do not see there):  Count nouns and [noncount] nouns used in a count sense can be pluralized; noncount nouns and nouns used in a noncount sense cannot.
  
Goodman  #532597  Thu, 26 Jun 08 12:12 AM

Hi MM,

Aside from the Google results which can be skewed by how the query was made. I think I can agree to a certain extent with respect to the “cream and wine” discussion. Is it because something is deemed as correct, even though folks are using the language improperly but accepted as the standard or the norm, or it's changing to simplify the complexity.  Sure, we hear it and I am too guilty saying it. Can I have two white wines ?  My point yesterday was, if I had to make a reference with someone using alot of creams, I said I would refer to creams as “cream products”. That’s was the context I made my argument in. In fact, I also had a discussion with my wife. She said “coffee cream?”.  I think we had enough “creams and wines” in this discussion and the points are understood. Thanks for you comments.

  
Anonymous  #555682  Sun, 17 Aug 08 03:58 AM
please  say me.
I make  detergent cream,but t don't think formula.Please say formula and consist chemicals.

email deleted by moderator