"The fact that before "Passion of the Christ" Hollywood treated pro-Christianity themes like the bird flu has become almost as cliched as kill-the-black-guy-first."
"It wasn't the pro-Christianity-ness of that film that scared people, was it? I thought it was the Aramaic with subtitles?"
Scared people? The only thing "scary" about that movie was the violence, which was most likely just the way it was. The fact is, Jesus wasn't on the cross as long as most were, because of the advent of a Jewish holiday. If it "scared" you it's probably because you're anti-Christian.
"I'm honestly puzzled by your statement too, Lois (I thought you were making a joke until this post)..."
I suppose almost a billion dollars scares you, too. That's no joke.
"Whenever we see a pro-Christianity character in a film, my ... oath that WGA writers have to take: Diss the Christian."
"Dissing control-hungry fundamentalists of any religion is easy, and kind of important to do in the face of the rising ... superimposed on storylines to make them palatable to "Christians." This has been done since at least the Hayes office days."
I think you don't see it because you're probably not Christian. My guess is (and feel free to correct me honestly) is that you're agnostic or even atheist, like all too many writers in Hollywood.
"In my experience, it's the rare film that doesn't "buy" its way into social graces by a third act conversion ... themselves Christian but also consider it their right to force their beliefs onto others something I have never seen you do."
Actually, that's not really Christian (or limited to it). REDEMPTION is the main theme of most positive films. That's VERY old, going back to the Upanishads and Vedas. Joseph Campbell's "The Hero of a Thousand Faces" goes into this. (Not that I'm a rabid Campbell fan, but he did spend five years studying the great stories and religions of the Earth.)
"Hollywood should take a page out of the sports industry's ... in black and white, that guy thought about the green."
"Yah, try making a film that celebrates atheism or godless communism. Fat freaking chance. Not since a bunch of intellectually curious and artistically and spiritually experimental filmmakers took advantage of created the old New Wave in France (and New York as much as L.A.)."
There you go, maybe I was right about you. The fact is, atheism and communism KILL CULTURES. And then there's the small fact of the millions murdered by Stalin, Mao, and all the other evil pigs straight out of George Orwell's "Animal Farm."
"That's what I'm saying Hollywood should do. More Americans go to church on Sunday than the combined attendance at sports events."
"And most Americans masturbate, but that doesn't mean it would make a good film."
Assuming "most" means over 50% I'm not sure that's true. There are a great number of people who don't - at least I trust them when they tell me they don't. Hollywood, on the other hand, makes movies like Kinsey, with an angry self-righteous Liam Neeson in the lead (I saw the talk shows where he promoted, that statement is based on observation). And they think they're doing some great social statement, ignoring the dark side of Kinsey and his own rather nasty predilections.
"We have money and we could be spending it on movies that don't insult our intelligence or beliefs."
"If you could find good stories that create dynamic conflict based in religion. It's a very tough trick."
Gee, Mel Gibson didn't have a problem with it. And Hollywood did it forever, but they stopped. Ever see "Angels with Dirty Faces"?
"Hollywood bean-counters need to wake up and smell the communion wafers."
"You need to do a little more reading about film history, and really LOOK at the themes being explored in most films today. Firmly Judaeo-Christian more often than not."
No they're not. The difference - and Lois is right here - is that Hollywood used to OPENLY make movies with Judaeo-Christian themes and have good priests and preachers and people doing what they considered morally right. Now more often than not when such themes arise, religion isn't mentioned. It's a thematic decline AWAY from most of the true values of most Americans, and that's what Lois is saying.
"And you also need to be able to tell the difference between characters that are mocked or villified because they ... for conflict). By the way, numerous articles have been written about fundie four-walling. Joe Bob says check it out! Mysti"
I love how Christians overall are labeled "fundamentalists" as if they're no better than "Islamic fundamentalists" who fly planes into skyscrapers and kill thousands.
The fact is, Wahabis (the evil Saudi version of Islam) are no more the fundamental representation of Islam than Pat Robertson is of most church-going Americans.
What Hollywood ignores is how much people in America want shows that reflect who they are, like Seventh Heaven, and how successful those shows are. Instead, Hollywood predominantly tries to sell how Hollywoodites are, which is often pretty damned twisted. And Americans watch it because that's what's available.
Hollywood makes half the money it could make every year because of this divergence.