dedication

   Share on Facebook  
Tuongvan  #480593  Sat, 23 Feb 08 08:13 AM

 Hi teachers,

When I want to give  a picture , a book etc.,  to a person I like or respect  (e.g.  friend of mine , my  teacher ...)can I  write on it a dedication as below ?:

1/ For/To  Mary , my best friend.

2/ For/To my best friend , Mary

3/ Dedicated to my teacher ,Mr J. Brown with respect on the occasion of the Teachers' Day

4/ Affectionately/respectfully dedicated to Mr J. Brown , my teacher on the occasion of the Teachers' Day

I'm sure these sentences sound  odd to  native speakers , so please help me with various ways of writing such dedications.

Thanks in advance

  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Sun, Dec 30 2007
Regular Member (585)
van
Doll  #480670  Sat, 23 Feb 08 02:01 PM

This is my take:  

I generally read "to my mother, to my husband" on the first page of the books. "Affectionally/ respectfully dedicated to someone" is correct.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Mar 10 2007
Turkey
Senior Member (2,519)
Moderator
I am a netizen!
Maple  #480797  Sat, 23 Feb 08 07:59 PM

If you're the author/editor, you can dedicate your book to sb by printing such words on it to show your respect or affection. But if you bought a book and gave it to sb, I don't know if you can dedicate it the him/her.

  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jul 11 2006
An ESL student in China
Contributing Member (1,110)
Tuongvan  #480921  Sun, 24 Feb 08 05:13 AM

 

Hi teachers .

I'm still unclear about what you said.I would appreciate very much if someone could edit my sentences below:

Situation : today is the Teachers' Day and I buy a greeting card to send to my teacher .Can I write on the greeting card as below :

1/Respectfully/Affectionately  dedicated to my teacher , J. Brown on the accasion of the Teachers'Day

1/ Dedicated to Mr J. Brown , my teacher with deep respect / affection on the accasion of the Teachers'Day

Thanks

  
Verade  #480934  Sun, 24 Feb 08 06:37 AM
Tuongvan

1/ For/To  Mary, my best friend.

2/ For/To my best friend, Mary.

3/ Dedicated with respect to my teacher, Mr J. Brown, on the occasion of the Teachers' Day.

4/ Affectionately/respectfully dedicated to Mr J. Brown, my teacher, on the occasion of the Teachers' Day.

 

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Dec 31 2007
Virginia USA
Full Member (180)
Vera-- "Life is either a daring adventure or nothing." --Helen Keller
Verade  #480936  Sun, 24 Feb 08 06:50 AM

Tuongvan

 

3/ Dedicated with respect to my teacher, Mr J. Brown, on the occasion of the Teachers' Day

 
  
Tuongvan  #480937  Sun, 24 Feb 08 06:57 AM

 

Thank you  Verade ever so much , but do you mean the words in red  e.g. TO in (1)  and FOR in (2)  are  preferrable or they are just the only  ones to be accepted ? and I wonder why in (3)  the before Teachers' Day is in red and the in (4) is crossed out .

Thank you very much if you would take the trouble to clarify these points for me

 

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service