Did + ing

   Share on Facebook  
Tania B  #34847  Mon, 28 Jun 04 02:02 AM
Someone I work with asked me whether 'I did studying' is a correct sentence. Initially I told the person that is was incorrect. Then I tought about it and realized that it is common to say 'I did some studying'. For example, if someone says ' What did you do last night?' - 'I did a some studying, I did a bit of reading etc..'

Are both 'I did studying' and 'I did some studying' correct? If only the second one is correct, why is that?

Thank you.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Jun 28 2004
New User (03)
Fairy  #34884  Mon, 28 Jun 04 03:56 PM



"i did study"
IS CORRECT:)
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Jun 28 2004
First Post (01)
taiwandave  #34940  Mon, 28 Jun 04 10:47 PM
1. I did some studying.
2. I did the studying I was supposed to do.
3. I did my studying.
4. I did studying.
5. I did homework

In [1], "studying" is being modified by the determiner "some" to indicate a quantity greater than zero. It's being used as a gerund (noun).

Similarly, in [2] and [3] "studying" is being treated as a noun.

But "studying" isn't a true noun. When it is the object of the verb "do", it needs determiners such as "some", "the" and "my" to identify it as a noun. Otherwise, its function becomes that of a verb. In [4], it is being used -- incorrectly -- as a verb.

"Homework", on the other hand, is a true noun, and therefore [5] is correct.

The correct past-tense form of this sentence is:

I studied last night.

If you wish to emphasize that you studied as opposed to doing something else, you can use the intensive form, which is the addition of "do" in an affirmative sentence:

I did study last night.
  
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jun 7 2004
Taoyuan City, Taiwan
Frequent Poster (287)
Proficient Speaker
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions