Did you go OR did you went

   Share on Facebook  
Teachmepls  #458677  Mon, 31 Dec 07 02:39 AM

Hi

I am not a native english speaker.People around me very often speak "Did you went"

not did you go.They are thinking "Went" is past tense verb and "go " is present tense verb ,

so "did you go" contains "Go" verb which is present tense so you need to say "Did you went " here

went is past tense verb it shows this is past tense.

Which is correct among these and why do we need to use present verb in past tense.

Help appreciated.

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Dec 31 2007
New Member (13)
CalifJim  #458682  Mon, 31 Dec 07 02:53 AM
The tense is carried by the auxiliary verb do -- not by the main verb.
Only the first of the three groups below can leave out the auxiliary and use the inflected forms of the main verb instead (like goes and went in the case of the verb go).

I do go; you do go; he does go; ...  I go; you go; he goes; ...
I did go; you did go; he did go; ...   I went; you went; he went; ...
___________

The remaining three groups never use the forms goes or went.

Do I go?  Do you go?  Does he go? ...
Did I go?  Did you go?  Did he go? ...

I do not go; you do not go; he does not go; ...
I did not go; you did not go; he did not go; ...

Don't I go?  Don't you go?  Doesn't he go? ...
Didn't I go?  Didn't you go?  Didn't he go? ...
__________

So Did you went? is totally wrong.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (18,315)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Teachmepls  #458980  Mon, 31 Dec 07 11:53 PM

Thanks CJ for the reply.

The tense is carried out by auxiliary verb in past tense, why do we need to change the past verb to bare infinity in question and negative form. such as "did you go " in other tense you dont alter verb

such as "i am going" "are you going"

why do we need to change the verb only in past tense.any specific reason.

Thanks

  
Grammar Geek  #458986  Tue, 01 Jan 08 12:37 AM

Because that's just how it works.

With I am going, going is the present progressive form of the word.

When you use a form of the verb "to do" you conjugate "to do" (he does, she did, etc.) and then use the bare infinitive. I did go. Do you go there often? He doesn't go there anymore.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Pennsylvania, USA
Veteran Member (16,645)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Barbara, who answers in American English.
CalifJim  #459050  Tue, 01 Jan 08 06:27 AM
why do we need to change the past verb to a bare infinity infinitive in question and negative form
Only one past marker is allowed within a single clause.  The auxiliary takes the past marker, so the main verb cannot.  The regular past marker is d, but some verbs are irregular, of course.  The past marker for do is did.  The past marker for go is went.  Since you can't have more than one past marker in the same clause, you can't have both did and went in the same clause.

You can express the affirmative forms without an auxiliary, so there the main verb takes the past marker.  It has to; it's the only verb in the sentence.

He went.

But if you express the affirmative with the auxiliary (the so-called "emphatic" form), did carries the past marker and so go cannot.

He did go.  (Never He did went.)

The question and negative forms always use the auxiliary so the main verb can never take the past marker in those cases.

He didn't go.  Did he go?  Didn't he go?

CJ

For more on grammatical tense markers, see Post:255817.

  
Anonymous  #627101  Wed, 31 Dec 08 12:35 AM
hi I migrated here in the states 2 years ago.. & I keep on hearing with my BS degree holder-co-workers... "Where did he/she went?" ... did is a past tense & so went... it's just like asking " what did you did?" instead of "what did you do"?




XYZ
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service