Click here to play!

Don't / Didn't

Click here to play
1 2
   Share on Facebook  
jack112  #134626  Wed, 07 Sep 05 04:14 AM

Scenario:

Yesterday: I'm talking to my pal about my fitness schedule. The fitness center guy didn't mail me any information.

Today: I'm there at the fitness center and they have figured out my schedule. My pal calls me and I say: "You know how I don't have my schedule? I had to go to that fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule."

I'm not sure if I should use 'don't' or 'didn't' ? I still don't have that schdule that they were supposed to mail to me. So are both of them fine?

1. You know how I don't have my schedule? I had to go to that fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule.

2. You know how I didn't have my schedule? I had to go to that fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule.

Thanks.

  
Top 100 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jul 22 2004
Regular Member (715)
Clive  #134645  Wed, 07 Sep 05 06:04 AM

Hi,

Yesterday: I'm talking to my pal about my fitness schedule. The fitness center guy didn't mail me any information.

Today: I'm there at the fitness center and they have figured out my schedule. My pal calls me and I say: "You know how I don't have my schedule? I had to go to that fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule."

I'm not sure if I should use 'don't' or 'didn't' ? I still don't have that schdule that they were supposed to mail to me. So are both of them fine?

1. You know how I don't have my schedule? I had to come to this fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule. "don't" means you still didn't get the schedule

2. You know how I didn't have my schedule? I had to come to this fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule. "didn't" means you didn't have it in the past but now, at the time of speaking, you do have it.

Best wishes, Clive

 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (20,469)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
ranchhand  #134736  Wed, 07 Sep 05 12:49 PM
 Clive wrote:

 

2. You know how I didn't have my schedule? I had to come to this fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule. "didn't" means you didn't have it in the past but now, at the time of speaking, you do have it.

Best wishes, Clive

There's nothing in this that means that this person is now in possession of the schedule. There could have been continued screw ups at the fitness center that precluded the speaker getting the schedule.

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Sun, May 15 2005
Junior Member (81)
goldmund  #134749  Wed, 07 Sep 05 01:42 PM

Dear Jack112,

It is a riddle, no? Smile [:)]

You called your friend yesterday. You told him that you did not have your schedule.

You call your friend today. He still knows that you did not have your schedule yesterday. But he does not know that you «don't have your schedule» today.

Therefore you say number 2:

«You know how I didn't have my schedule? I had to go to that fitness center so early today to figure out my schedule.»

It does not matter if you have your schedule now or not. It is what your friend knows that matters. Smile [:)]

Kind regards,

Goldmund

  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Fri, Jun 10 2005
Regular Member (581)
«Tout homme peut dire véritablement; mais dire ordonnément, prudemment et suffisamment, peu d'hommes le peuvent.» - Michel de Montaigne
pieanne  #134785  Wed, 07 Sep 05 03:49 PM

Couldn't we replace "how" by "why"?

 

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 20 2005
South of France ...But I'm Belgian!
Veteran Member (7,512)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
I'm glad to help, but I'm not a native! And please excuse my typos...
CalifJim  #135227  Thu, 08 Sep 05 05:59 PM
As in "You know why I didn't have my schedule?"???
No, I wouldn't make that substitution.  It changes the meaning.
With "how", the implication is that the other person does know.
With "why" it becomes a true question asking "Do you know why I didn't have my schedule?"
The first asks the other person to recall something already known.
The second asks the other person to provide a reason or explanation.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (16,567)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
pieanne  #135242  Thu, 08 Sep 05 06:25 PM

Then "how" as in "how come" ?

Thanks, CJ!

 

  
CalifJim  #135320  Thu, 08 Sep 05 11:20 PM
Pieanne,
No.  I still think that "how" means something different from "how come" (the equivalent of "why") in that sentence.
Example:  The sentence below doesn't ask for information about the methods of translation.  It asks you to recall an incident or event.  The intent is to elicit an affirmative - a recognition of the incident or event - with the further intent to speak at greater length on the subject once the questioner has oriented the listener to the topic at hand.

"Do you know how I translated some material from French a few months ago?"

So the "how" means neither "why" nor its equivalent "how come".
In fact, "Do you know how I ...?" means "Can you recall that I ...?" or simply, "Recall that I ...".

CJ
(I hope I interpreted your last post correctly in my response!)

  
pieanne  #135466  Fri, 09 Sep 05 09:15 AM

Yes, perfectly!

I had never come across that expression, but now it makes perfect sense, thanks Smile [:)] . I guess we use about the same in French, only it's "You know when I didn't find that letter? Well, I just found it in the the microwave!" Thanks again.

 

  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions