fall

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #380438  Sat, 16 Jun 07 07:28 PM

Hi,

I recently learned that the word 'fall' can mean "to happen on a particular day or at a particular time, but I don't understand its usage very well. e.g.

1."New Year's Day falls/fell on a Monday this year."

I have two questions about the sentence above.

a) Should we use 'falls' or 'fell' in the case above?

b) Could I use be verb instead of 'falls' or 'fell' here, as in

  "New Year's Day is/ was on a Monday this year."

 If so, should we use 'is' or 'was' here?

2."Labor Day is/falls on May 1st."

Are 'falls' and 'is' interchangeable here?

Thank you very much.

  
Feebs11  #380515  Sat, 16 Jun 07 11:59 PM
 Anonymous wrote:

Hi,

I recently learned that the word 'fall' can mean "to happen on a particular day or at a particular time, but I don't understand its usage very well. e.g.

1."New Year's Day falls/fell on a Monday this year." 

I have two questions about the sentence above.

a) Should we use 'falls' or 'fell' in the case above?

b) Could I use be verb instead of 'falls' or 'fell' here, as in

  "New Year's Day is/ was on a Monday this year."

 If so, should we use 'is' or 'was' here?

Since you are necessarily talking about a past event, you will use "fell" and "was". If you were talking about next year's New Year's Day, then you can use "falls" and "is". 

2."Labor Day is/falls on May 1st."

Are 'falls' and 'is' interchangeable here?  They can both be used as the date changes annually [actually, the first Monday in September]

 Thank you very much.

 

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Nov 23 2006
UK
Senior Member (4,922)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Spectacled-Girl  #380669  Sun, 17 Jun 07 02:11 PM
I thought 'fall' is a past tense and 'fell' is a present tense? I am confused. Please explain. Thanks.
  
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on Fri, May 25 2007
Singapore
Full Member (351)
Play hard, study hard.
Francesca  #380671  Sun, 17 Jun 07 02:14 PM

It's the opposite: fall is the present and fell is the past, in fact it is fall-fell-fallen.

I hope it helps Smile [:)]

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Oct 11 2005
Grand Duchy of Tuscany
Contributing Member (1,619)
Moderator
Spectacled-Girl  #380678  Sun, 17 Jun 07 02:30 PM
Thanks Francesca! You have helped me a lot! Big Smile [:D]
  
Anonymous  #380685  Sun, 17 Jun 07 02:41 PM

Hi,
Thank you, feebs11 for your reply.
I have two more questions about the topic as follows:

Question #1
e.g.
1. "New Year's Day was on a Monday this year."
2. "New Year's Day was a Monday this year."
Which sentence is correct?

Question #2
e.g.
"New Years's Day falls on January 1st every year."
Is it fine to use 'falls' in the sentence?

Thanks


 

  
Feebs11  #380824  Sun, 17 Jun 07 11:13 PM
 Anonymous wrote:

Hi,
Thank you, feebs11 for your reply.
I have two more questions about the topic as follows:

Question #1
e.g.
1. "New Year's Day was on a Monday this year."
2. "New Year's Day was a Monday this year."
Which sentence is correct?  Both - as is "This year, New Year's Day was [on] a Monday".

Question #2
e.g.
"New Year's Day falls on January 1st every year."
Is it fine to use 'falls' in the sentence? Yes.

Thanks


Big Smile [:D]
  
Anonymous  #380986  Mon, 18 Jun 07 11:31 AM

Hi,

Thank you so much, Feebs11.

  
Feebs11  #381023  Mon, 18 Jun 07 01:51 PM
You're welcome  Big Smile [:D]
  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL Vocabulary and Idioms
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service