Click here to play

*Feature

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
maverick88  #79340  Mon, 07 Mar 05 09:09 PM
The film features James Dean as a disaffected teenager


1) May I write it as:
This film is featured by JD as a disaffected teenager?

2) If I want this in passive:
James Dean is featured by the film as a disaffected teenager ---> doesn't it lose it's original meaning?

Thanks
  
Top 100 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 22 2004
Israel
Regular Member (695)
An English learner
nona the brit  #79341  Mon, 07 Mar 05 09:12 PM
He cannot be featured by the film. It needs to be featured in.

1) This does not make sense as the film is not featured in JD.

2)This is ok with 'in the film'...
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Sep 22 2004
England
Veteran Member (11,347)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
The name says it all.
maverick88  #79342  Mon, 07 Mar 05 09:21 PM
The film features James Dean as a disaffected teenager

Is the following correct and equivalent in its meaning?
1) JD is featured in the film as...

2)
How would you say the sentence beneath by using 'feature' and not as in (1)?
"The film is characterized by JD's playing the main role (leading role?)"

Thanks
  
nona the brit  #79344  Mon, 07 Mar 05 09:49 PM
Featured does not work in this way. All it means is that he stars in the film.

  
maverick88  #79346  Mon, 07 Mar 05 10:07 PM
Yes, he stars in the film -- that's the meaning it should have conveyed. What did you mean by 'doesn't work in this way'? As you said, he stars, he is pointed out; doesn't it mean that he is featured IN* the film?
Nona, I'd be grateful if you explained what exactly you meant.
Thanks.
  
nona the brit  #79347  Mon, 07 Mar 05 10:15 PM
He stars by the film - no.
He stars in the film - yes.
He is starred by the film - no
He is starring in the film - yes

He features by the film - no.
He features in the film - yes.
He is featured by the film - no
He is featured in the film - yes.

  
nona the brit  #79348  Mon, 07 Mar 05 10:17 PM
He stars by the film - no.
He stars in the film - yes.
He is starred by the film - no
He is starring in the film - yes

He features by the film - no.
He features in the film - yes.
He is featured by the film - no
He is featured in the film - yes.

The film stars XX - yes.
The film features XX - yes.

  
maverick88  #79352  Mon, 07 Mar 05 10:23 PM
Sorry, in my last message it was supposed to be 'in' insread of 'by', I've modified it. The examples you brough up here were explained previously, I understood them but you said that 'featured' isn't used in 'this way' after I posted:
1) JD is featured in the film as...


What's the mistake here?

It even suits your pattern:
He is featured in the film - yes
  
nona the brit  #79375  Mon, 07 Mar 05 11:07 PM
Oh I see, no that part is fine. It was the other question

2)
How would you say the sentence beneath by using 'feature' and not as in (1)?
"The film is characterized by JD's playing the main role (leading role?)"

that I couldn't really follow and there does not seem to be a way of using feature in it.

  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service