from/since/own

   Share on Facebook  
Newguest  #568778  Sun, 21 Sep 08 05:36 PM

Hi

Is it possible to say: It's a little shop of my own instead of It's my own little shop.

 

Can I use both: From Monday to Friday AND Since Monday to Friday.

 

Thanks

  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Sun, Feb 25 2007
Contributing Member (1,201)
Cool Breeze  #568793  Sun, 21 Sep 08 06:10 PM
 1. Yes, if you have several shops.

2. No.

CB

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Fri, Apr 7 2006
Helsinki, Finland
Senior Member (2,962)
Proficient SpeakerTrusted Users
The coldest winter I ever spent was a summer in San Francisco.- Mark Twain
Newguest  #568796  Sun, 21 Sep 08 06:17 PM

Cool Breeze
 1. Yes, if you have several shops.

 

2. No.

CB

Hi

Several shops?

So, I guess that the one with "from" IS correct?

  
Cool Breeze  #568801  Sun, 21 Sep 08 06:24 PM
Newguest

So, I guess that the one with "from" IS correct?

 

Yes. Sorry that I forgot to mention it. Embarrassed

CB

  
Newguest  #568803  Sun, 21 Sep 08 06:29 PM

Hi

But I still do not get why I have to have several shops to say that. I go with my friend and we pass by my shop where I work and then I tell him: Look this is my own little shop and I'm very proud that I have it (where does it imply that I have more shops than only this one???)

 

Regarding the second question: Why is "since" incorrect? We can use it only with the present tenses???

Thanks

  
Cool Breeze  #568822  Sun, 21 Sep 08 07:35 PM
1. The use of the indefinite article implies that more than one shop are involved. On second thought, I'm trying to envisage a conversation with "it's a little shop of my own"... Thinking Perhaps it could be used even if you have only one. People don't always go by the book (= the grammar book Smile) when they speak and write.

For example, it says in all grammar books that the combination the ... + of one's own is wrong. In other words, we shouldn't say: This is the car of my own. Yet an English pop singer called Cliff Richard sold a million records (or more, I don't know) singing:

And some day when the years have flown

darling, then we'll teach the young ones of our own.

- The Young Ones

 2. You can say from Monday to/till/until Friday. Since instead of from is wrong simply because native speakers don't use it with to/till/until. It has nothing to do with tense. There is no verb in your original example.

CB

  
Newguest  #568834  Sun, 21 Sep 08 08:24 PM

Thanks. I think I understand it now Wink

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service