Gerund

   Share on Facebook  
Optimus  #317841  Sun, 21 Jan 07 02:39 AM
Hello. First, in the following sentence, is 'adding' a gerund?

Adding comments (has/have) been disabled for this video.

If yes, is 'comments' part of this gerund also?
Second, what should follow 'adding comments'? While 'comments' is a plural, shouldn't 'adding comments' be considered a single activity?

Finally, I was wondering whether 'what pumpkins being dropped off a building' takes a plural verb.
i.e., Ever wonder what pumpkins being dropped off a building (look/looks) like?
My guess is 'looks', but it's kind of confusing because without 'being dropped off a building', it takes a plural verb.

Your input is appreciated.
Thank you
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Jul 26 2005
Junior Member (70)
Could the true reason we fear the unknown be that we know ourselves too well? -The Outer Limits
Clive  #317876  Sun, 21 Jan 07 06:08 AM

Hi,

First, in the following sentence, is 'adding' a gerund? Yes.

Adding comments (has/have) been disabled for this video.

If yes, is 'comments' part of this gerund also? I think of it as the object of 'adding'.
Second, what should follow 'adding comments'? While 'comments' is a plural, shouldn't 'adding comments' be considered a single activity? Yes, so say 'has'.

If I wanted to write more carefully, I would write this as The function (or method, or ability) to add comments has been disabled for this video.

[ How would you add comments to a video, anyway? ]

Finally, I was wondering whether 'what pumpkins being dropped off a building' takes a plural verb.
i.e., Ever wonder what pumpkins being dropped off a building (look/looks) like?
My guess is 'looks', but it's kind of confusing because without 'being dropped off a building', it takes a plural verb. 

The subject of the verb 'look' is the plural 'pumpkins', so say Ever wonder what pumpkins being dropped off a building look like?

On the other hand, you could say Ever wonder what dropping pumpkins off a building looks like?

Best wishes, Clive
 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (22,243)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
CalifJim  #317881  Sun, 21 Jan 07 06:24 AM
Hmmm.  I don't know.

Thinking in terms of a notional subject, I would accept "pumpkins being dropped off a building" as "the activity of dropping pumpkins off a building", and therefore find the following acceptable.

Ever wonder what pumpkins being dropped off a building looks like?


I think the question is how the activity in general looks, not how the pumpkins look as they are acted upon during this activity.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (17,568)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Clive  #317885  Sun, 21 Jan 07 06:50 AM

Hi CJ,

I know what you are saying. Perhaps you can say it either way, depending on your meaning.

It sounds OK to say Ever wonder what men being hanged look like? if you are focusing on the men, their faces, etc.

But you could also say Ever wonder what men being hanged looks like? if you mean the whole activity.

However, dropping pumpkins off a building or hanging men does clarify that one means the activity.

Clive

  
Inchoateknowledge  #317918  Sun, 21 Jan 07 08:53 AM
 Optimus wrote:
Hello. First, in the following sentence, is 'adding' a gerund?

Adding comments (has/have) been disabled for this video.

If yes, is 'comments' part of this gerund also?
Second, what should follow 'adding comments'? While 'comments' is a plural, shouldn't 'adding comments' be considered a single activity?

Finally, I was wondering whether 'what pumpkins being dropped off a building' takes a plural verb.
i.e., Ever wonder what pumpkins being dropped off a building (look/looks) like?
My guess is 'looks', but it's kind of confusing because without 'being dropped off a building', it takes a plural verb.

Your input is appreciated.
Thank you


Adding comments (has/have) been disabled for this video.

the gerund phrase in red is the subject.
comments = direct object of action expressed in gerund
has been disabled -- verb
  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Wed, May 3 2006
Senior Member (2,536)
Beep! Beep! :)
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service