has been based

   Share on Facebook  
New2grammar  #519079  Mon, 26 May 08 01:28 PM
British troops had been based in Basra city since the Iraq war began in 2003. The country handed over security control to Iraqis late last year, but still maintains a presence in Basra province.

Shouldn't it be "has' instead of 'had' since the troops are still stationed in Basra?Thanks.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Nov 21 2006
Veteran Member (7,670)
Who wants to go sailing around the world with me?
Clive  #519081  Mon, 26 May 08 01:36 PM

Hi,

British troops had been based in Basra city since the Iraq war began in 2003. The country handed over security control to Iraqis late last year, but still maintains a presence in Basra province.

Shouldn't it be "has' instead of 'had' since the troops are still stationed in Basra?

The past perfect places the fact before some time in the past. That time may be the time that 'the country handed over . . ', or it might be some other time mentioned earlier in the context that we do not have here.

You could use the present perfect, but that changes the meaning by relating the the fact to the present time. if you choose to do this, say 'have' and not 'has' because the word 'troops' is plural.

Best wishes, Clive

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (21,237)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
New2grammar  #519084  Mon, 26 May 08 01:43 PM

"Mid-afternoon I sat in a Basra street cafe and had a cup of tea with General Mohammed Juwad Huwaidi, commander of the Iraqi forces in Basra. All around us were the signs of a city returning to normality -- shop keepers working away, women walking around wearing head scarves and children playing on their bikes."

Maj. Tom Holloway, the British military spokesman, told CNN on Friday that Browne discussed security plans with British commanders and met with local Iraqi military officials during the three-hour visit.

British troops had been based in Basra city since the Iraq war began in 2003. The country handed over security control to Iraqis late last year, but still maintains a presence in Basra province.

Thanks, Clive. It's my mistake to suggest the singular present perfect. In this context, I feel though the change cause the meaning to change by relating to thhe present time, it doesn't change the results or cause any disconnection from the previous or following idea. Am I right to say that in this context?

  
Clive  #519323  Mon, 26 May 08 09:36 PM

Hi,

Well, have British troops been based in Basra during the period from Browne's discussion to the present time? Or were they just there in the period prior to Browne's discussion?

Best wishes, Clive

  
New2grammar  #519327  Mon, 26 May 08 09:48 PM

I think I get it now. Thanks, Clive.

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service