Have or get

   Share on Facebook  
Bamtori  #217922  Thu, 20 Apr 06 07:11 AM

"Usually when you have a boob job, you get these two big blobs in the middle of nowhere,..."

Teachers,

After all this time of learning English, I'm still having trouble with when to use "have" and not "get" and vice versa.

Please help~

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jul 25 2005
Junior Member (99)
milky  #217926  Thu, 20 Apr 06 07:36 AM
 Bamtori wrote:

"Usually when you have a boob job, you get these two big blobs in the middle of nowhere,..."

Teachers,

After all this time of learning English, I'm still having trouble with when to use "have" and not "get" and vice versa.

Please help~

In the first clause, you can use either. Formally, we use "have" in such situation when we arrange to have something done to or for us. Informally, we can use "get". The second clause talks about the result and we can use "get" or expressions such as "end with" or "end up with".

Formally: "I'm having a boob job." (Arranging to have a boob job.)

Informally: I'm getting a boob job." (There, "getting" could also mean "purchasing", but probably means "arranging to have".)

Other examples:

I'm having/getting my hair cut.

She's having/getting the house painted next week.

He had/got his car fixed so we can now go away for the weekend.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 15 2004
Senior Member (3,149)
Hume said that if we had perfect or complete descriptive knowledge of reality, we could not, by reasoning, derive a single valid "ought".
rishonly  #217933  Thu, 20 Apr 06 08:01 AM
 Milky wrote:
 Bamtori wrote:

"Usually when you have a boob job, you get these two big blobs in the middle of nowhere,..."

Teachers,

After all this time of learning English, I'm still having trouble with when to use "have" and not "get" and vice versa.

Please help~

In the first clause, you can use either. Formally, we use "have" in such situation when we arrange to have something done to or for us. Informally, we can use "get". The second clause talks about the result and we can use "get" or expressions such as "end with" or "end up with".

Formally: "I'm having a boob job." (Arranging to have a boob job.)

Informally: I'm getting a boob job." (There, "getting" could also mean "purchasing", but probably means "arranging to have".)

Other examples:

I having/getting my hair cut.

She having/getting the house painted next week.

He had/got his car fixed so we can now go away for the weekend.

I [am] having/getting my hair cut.

She [is] having/getting the house painted next week.

These sentences are missing "am" and "is", respectively.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Mar 5 2005
KUMBAKONAM,INDIA
Contributing Member (1,781)
Moderator
Regards, Krish
milky  #217937  Thu, 20 Apr 06 08:10 AM
 Rishonly wrote:

I [am] having/getting my hair cut.

She [is] having/getting the house painted next week.

These sentences are missing "am" and "is", respectively.

Wow, thanks for being so awake there, Rish. It's early here and I'm still asleep.

  
rishonly  #217943  Thu, 20 Apr 06 08:18 AM
Oh, that's fine Milky, and it  happens to all of us, rarely .Smile [:)]
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service