Rotter,
I think you misunderstand the use of the asterisk (*).
In giving examples of sentences, linguists and grammarians place an
asterisk in front of sentences, phrases, and words which are
ungrammatical. So the asterisk means: "This is wrong.
Don't use this."
Your second sentence should be written to show that it contains a grammatical mistake, like this:
*I wish my refrigerator would be a colour that matched the other appliances.
The point is that the refrigerator has no power to change its
color! There's no point in wishing for something that cannot
happen! We can only wish things
would be a certain way if
the wish can come true through some action on the part of the
subject. The refrigerator cannot paint itself a different
colour.
CJ