I'm confuzzled! : In vs On vs At

   Share on Facebook  
HMFindlay  #194178  Wed, 08 Feb 06 04:01 PM

In vs On vs At

Why can't I say ' I prefer to stay in home' but have to say 'at home' when I am inside the house?

or 'Im at the airport' instead of 'in the airport' when I am already inside the arriving hall?

And why 'my dog plays in the field/playground' and not 'at the field/playground' or something else?

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Dec 19 2005
KL
Full Member (108)
- Get what you can and keep what you have; that's the way to get rich -
CalifJim  #194212  Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:21 PM
at home is just a special idiom.  If you want to emphasize staying inside, that is, the interiority of the situation, use in the house.  If you want to emphasize that you don't want to leave the house (Maybe there's a dangerous animal just outside the door!), then say that you want to stay in the house.  If you want to emphasize that you don't want to participate in social activities in the world at large (shopping, going to a restaurant, going to work, etc.), then say you want to stay at home.

You can say at the airport when you are in the airport.

You can say that your dog plays at the playground.

home, airport, and playground can be conceived of as places where certain typical activities occur.  When they are conceived of in this way, we use at.
When we conceive of such places simply as delimited volumes -- i.e., objects with interiors (house, airport) -- or delimited areas (field), we use in.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (16,966)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Goodman  #194219  Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:32 PM
 HMFindlay wrote:

In vs On vs At

Why can't I say ' I prefer to stay in home' but have to say 'at home' when I am inside the house?

or 'Im at the airport' instead of 'in the airport' when I am already inside the arriving hall?

And why 'my dog plays in the field/playground' and not 'at the field/playground' or something else?

Hi,

Questions about preposition indeed is confusing to a lot of ESL students. I had been there ! I know! Some of them just have to be memorized and used often because explanation may not make sense, i.e. “We were at sea for 4 days with no sight of land”. I will try to give some examples to help you understand.  If I am wrong, maybe others can pitch in.

“At” suggests very close proximity Ex: 1) “ I will be waiting for you at the corner of  Nathan Rd and Jordan”. 2) “We were at the movie last night”; not “in”. However you were in the theater.

A: “Where are you at; we are looking for you?”   B: “I am at my cousin’s house”

Also keep in mind the following:

I’ve just arrived at the airport.

I am waiting for you at the taxi stand.

You are still at the ball park!

Children were playing:  In the playground / At  the park/ On the soccer field/

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 7 2005
Calif. USA
Senior Member (3,192)
The name says it all!
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service