Schetin wrote: |
Goodman wrote: | | ... but all in all, the grammar rules still applies. Simply, "in according" is bad English. The logical usage with "according" are "according to" or "in accordance with/ to". Some absolutely agianst the usage of "In accordance to", but this is used quite often. I am not a grammarian and I am not going to debate the ligitimacy of this usage. But "according" is an adverbial phrase and has nothing to do with the gerund for, or participle form. |
|
Probably, you mix up parts of speech and functions. Whatever function, 'according' is either gerund or present participle. 'According to' is an adverbial phrase, I agree, but you haven't proved it, because you haven't defined whether it's a gerund or a present participle form.
"In according" should be gerund because of the preposition 'in' - that's why it can't do the job of an adverb, which present participle can. But then you should get rid of the preposition 'in'. Hence 'according to'.
As I have said, it's either you choose 'in' before 'according' and use a direct object afterwards or get rid of 'in' and use 'to'.
Goodman, as far as I remember, you are an engineer majoring in electricity or something like that, right? Switch on your logic.
|
|
Schetin,
Thanks for taking the time to reply.
I think you are trying to share with us your brand of humor but I am not amused. My logic is always at work. May I return a favor by suggesting that you review the “part of speech”. First. to my knowledge, there is no such usage as “in according”. Secondly, According is not a gerund, nor a present participle; it's an adverb if I am not mistaken.
<<<<Probably, you mix up parts of speech and functions. Whatever function, 'according' is either gerund or present participle. (I don't think so) 'According to' is an adverbial phrase, I agree, but you haven't proved it, because you haven't defined whether it's a gerund or a present participle form. (Did you read my last post? I said it's neither a gerund, nor a present participle9:11:20 PM
"In according" should be gerund because of the preposition 'in' ( Nah! not true) - that's why it can't do the job of an adverb, which present participle can. But then you should get rid of the preposition 'in'. Hence 'according to'.
As I have said, it's either you choose 'in' before 'according' and use a direct object afterwards or get rid of 'in' and use 'to'. (Ok, if you say so, but I never heard of that in my life
)
Goodman, as far as I remember, you are an engineer majoring in electricity or something like that, right? Switch on your logic.>>>>>>> (I am afraid the logic I use may present a little difficulty for you to preceive).![Wink [;)]](/emoticons/emotion-5.gif)