Indirect question

   Share on Facebook  
hanuman_2000  #88042  Fri, 08 Apr 05 05:04 AM
Hello Teachers,

1.Which car is yours?

The indirect question for (1)

2.Can you tell me Which car is yours?

3.Can you tell me whic car yours is?

What is subject of the sentence (1)?

Thanks.
  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Aug 12 2004
INDIA
Contributing Member (1,625)
paco2004  #88048  Fri, 08 Apr 05 06:35 AM
Hello Hanuman

This car is yours. -> Which car is yours? [subject : which car]
Indirect question: Can you tell me which car is yours.

paco
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Nov 17 2004
Senior Member (4,095)
In Japan today even dogs are learning how to bow-wow in English.
Anonymous  #155285  Sat, 05 Nov 05 12:28 AM
Which car is yours?-Is it a direct question?
  
Mister Micawber  #155287  Sat, 05 Nov 05 12:31 AM

Yes it is.  An indirect question would be:

She asked me which car was mine.


(I told her it was the red Porsche Carrera GT.)


  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Aug 4 2004
Yokohama
Veteran Member (22,636)
SystemAdministratorTeachers
'The question is,' said Humpty Dumpty, 'which is to be master-- that's all.'
rishonly  #155293  Sat, 05 Nov 05 12:43 AM

Hello MM,

Which car is yours?

In the above question, Subject + Verb order has been used. Is it OK to use to S+V order in direct questions? Thanks in advance.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Mar 5 2005
KUMBAKONAM,INDIA
Contributing Member (1,781)
Moderator
Regards, Krish
Mister Micawber  #155297  Sat, 05 Nov 05 12:54 AM

I suppose that it depends (on what, I don't know offhand).

What time is it?
Which thief stole my hubcaps?
What kind of person would willlfully scratch a man's Porsche?
Your car is red, isn't it?
What happened to my fender?






  
rishonly  #155302  Sat, 05 Nov 05 01:01 AM
Thanks, MM. I will further study on this topic and get back to you with some additional questions.
  
CalifJim  #155344  Sat, 05 Nov 05 04:53 AM
The usual interpretation of "Which car is yours?" puts "which car" in the subject position.
That gives the indirect question in 2.  (Can you tell me which car is yours?)

However, this is an equative sentence (X is Y), and there is often an interpretation of such sentences which puts the last element ("yours") in the subject position.
That gives the indirect question in 3.  (Can you tell me which car yours is?)

It's a matter of interpretation:  Does the original direct question ask for an answer of the form "That one is mine" or an answer of the form "Mine is that one"?  Only the speaker who asks knows what is in his mind when he asks!

Note the difference:

-- Look at all the cars.  That red car is Barry's car.  That black one is Steve's car.
-- Can you tell me which car is yours?
-- Yes.  The blue car is mine.

-- Look at all the cars.  Barry's car is that red one.  Steve's car is that black one.
-- Can you tell me which car yours is?
-- Yes.  Mine is the blue one.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (17,747)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service