Is it ok without articles?

   Share on Facebook  
Maple  #278237  Mon, 09 Oct 06 03:26 PM
 
In the films of those day, all too often it was the same one: boy tractor meets girl tractor driver; they fall in love and drive tractors together.
 
 
Question: Do you think the highlighted part without any articles is ok?
 
 
Thanks a lot!
  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jul 11 2006
An ESL student in China
Contributing Member (1,110)
Grammar Geek  #278243  Mon, 09 Oct 06 03:33 PM

Yes, in this case - because there is an idiom of "boy meets girl" as a way to describe a story.
(Boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy and girl make up and live happily ever after.)

But if you wanted to relate the entire story in a true narrative format, you would use the articles. ("A boy met this girl. He... the girl. They both...")

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Pennsylvania, USA
Veteran Member (15,583)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Barbara, who answers in American English.
Clive  #278289  Mon, 09 Oct 06 04:45 PM

Hi GG,

("A boy met this girl. He... the girl. They both...")

Yes, yes . . . and then, and then . . . ? You're not just going to stop when it's getting interesting, are you?Smile [:)]

Clive

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (21,184)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Yankee  #278292  Mon, 09 Oct 06 04:54 PM
 Maple wrote:
 
In the films of those day, all too often it was the same one: boy tractor meets girl tractor driver; they fall in love and drive tractors together.


"Boy tractor meets girl tractor driver" sounds sort of kinky.  Surprise [:O]
Saying "boy tractor driver meets girl tractor driver" would sound more "normal" to me. Wink [;)]
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Apr 15 2006
Connecticut, USA
Senior Member (4,157)
ModeratorTeachers
Amy "You can't depend on your eyes when your imagination is out of focus." - Mark Twain
Grammar Geek  #278294  Mon, 09 Oct 06 04:57 PM
A boy met this girl. They both had a fascination with grammar. The girl's family did not approve - he was from the school that did not use the Oxford comma. But she insisted it did not matter. Until the day she saw him use his red pen on a semi-colon; this was her pet punctuation mark. She was devastated, but agreed with her family that a relationship could not be sustained amidst such differences. Sadly, she bid him farewell. He tried to woo her back. He even sent love notes with deliberate errors, to give her the excuse to correct them and send them back, so desperate was he for even one simple note. Their mutual friend, who was a professor in computer languages, decided to try to win the girl for himself. Although she was fascinated by computer syntax, she was not fascinated by him in a romantic sense. She embarked in a new direction, computational linguistics, with him as her mentor in academics, but not in love. In the IT department, surrounded by programmers who called apostrophes "those floating comma things," and who rearely used its and it's correctly in their own papers, she realized arguments over the Oxford comma mattered not at all. The boy and girl were reunited. And although he never used the semi-colon himself, he reached a state of detante over it, with peaceful co-existence. The boy and girl lived happily ever after, with a quibble of children, all of whom pursued non-literary interests.
  
Yankee  #278300  Mon, 09 Oct 06 05:04 PM
I love your story, Barbara! Big Smile [:D]
  
Maple  #278303  Mon, 09 Oct 06 05:15 PM
 Grammar Geek wrote:

Yes, in this case - because there is an idiom of "boy meets girl" as a way to describe a story.
(Boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy and girl make up and live happily ever after.)

But if you wanted to relate the entire story in a true narrative format, you would use the articles. ("A boy met this girl. He... the girl. They both...")

Thank you Barbara!Smile [:)]Coffee [C]

And, wooooooo, what a lovely little story!Big Smile [:D]

  
Grammar Geek  #278304  Mon, 09 Oct 06 05:20 PM
It's dedicated to Clive. Smile [:)]
  
Clive  #278305  Mon, 09 Oct 06 05:20 PM
Smile [:)]Big Smile [:D]Smile [:)]
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service