This question is Not Answered
Latest post Mon, Dec 29 2003 7:05 PM by Guest. 2 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
Guest  +  17396 Mon, 29 Dec 03 07:05 PM
So that I may be a better home schooling parent for my teenage daughter, please confirm or correct the following for me. Thank you so much!


Person who is doing the lying down:

I lay, I was lying; I lie, I am lying; I will lie, I will be lying
You lay, you were lying; you lie, you are lying; you will lie, you will be lying
He/she lay, she was lying; she lies, she is lying; she will lie, she will be lying

This was where I felt confused:

Talking about putting something down:

I laid it downyesterday, I was laying it down; I lay it down today, I am laying it down; I will lay it down, I will be laying it down.
You laid it down, you were laying it down; you lay it down (now), you are laying it down; you will lay it down, you will be laying it down
She laid it down, She was laying it down; she lays it down, she is laying it down; she will lay it down, she will be laying it down
Pemmican  +  17556 Tue, 30 Dec 03 10:57 PM
Ok, here we go:

Actually, you have two different verbs here:
1) to lie ("to lie [by itself]"), past tense: lay, past participle: lain, present participle: lying
2) to lay ("to make sth. lie"), past tense & past perfect: laid, present participle: laying

The difference is NOT that someone is "doing the laying down" vs. " putting something down" but:
1) someone or something is lying down (by itself) - eg: I'm lying in bed
2) someone lays something down (in order to make it lie) - eg: I'm laying the pencil on the table (The result is that the pencil then will be lying (NOT laying) on the table)

According to this, the forms are:

1) I lie (in bed) - I lay (in bed) - I've lain (in bed) - I was lying (in bed) - I'll lie (in bed) - I'll be lying (in bed)

1) He lies (in bed) - he lay (in bed) - he's lain (in bed) - he was lying (in bed) - he'll lie (in bed) - he'll be lying (in bed)

and

2) I lay (it down) - I laid (it down) - I've laid (it down) - I was laying (it down) - I'll lay (it down) - I'll be laying (it down)

2) He lays (it down) - he laid (it down) - he's laid (it down) - he was laying (it down) - he'll lay (it down) - he'll be laying (it down)



Ok?
Hope that helps Smile [:)]
Joined on Thu, Aug 21 2003
Westphalia, Germany
Regular Member 569
Wâ mag ich mich nu vinden? wâ mac ich mich nu suochen, wâ? nu bin ich hie und bin ouch dâ und enbin doch weder dâ noch hie. wer wart ouch sus verirret ie?wer wart ie sus...
Sharon McEwan  +  17625 Wed, 31 Dec 03 05:45 AM
Dear Pemmican,

You clarified my question and my answer. Thank you very much and Happy New Year!
Joined on Mon, Dec 29 2003
New Member 01

XING

© MediaCet Ltd. 2009. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please contact us with proof of the poster's email, and we'll remove them immediately.