Name's/Name

   Share on Facebook  
Terr3  #388235  Thu, 05 Jul 07 10:40 AM
Hi!
His painting is similar to Van Gough

Can anyone explain to me why wasn't this thrase go like this:
'His painting is similar to Van Gough's.'

To me, 'His painting is similar to Van Gough' is more like this person's painting looks like Van Gough himself, the appearance of Van Gough. But that doesn't make sense.
'His painting is similar to Van Gough's.' is more likely meaning this person's painting looks like Van Gough's painting.

I have met across several times people would take it as a mistake by using 's. Like this one:

"Hati's theory" is one of the most profound invention by Hati.

Someone came to me and rewrite it as just the 'Hati theory'. I took it as it was a mistake.

Was I wrong?

Thank you in advance. -Terr3

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Wed, May 30 2007
the other side of mirror
Full Member (163)
Philip  #388368  Thu, 05 Jul 07 05:02 PM

 Terr3 wrote:
Hi! His painting is similar to Van Gough Can anyone explain to me why wasn't this thrase go like this: 'His painting is similar to Van Gough's.' To me, 'His painting is similar to Van Gough' is more like this person's painting looks like Van Gough himself, the appearance of Van Gough. But that doesn't make sense. 'His painting is similar to Van Gough's.' is more likely meaning this person's painting looks like Van Gough's painting. I have met across several times people would take it as a mistake by using 's. Like this one: "Hati's theory" is one of the most profound invention by Hati. Someone came to me and rewrite it as just the 'Hati theory'. I took it as it was a mistake. Was I wrong? Thank you in advance. -Terr3

I believe that the people you have come across are wrong and that you are right.

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
USA Pacific Northwest (Seattle)
Veteran Member (6,328)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
At reise er at leve! - H. C. Andersen
Terr3  #388773  Fri, 06 Jul 07 04:50 PM
Thank you Philip
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service