We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


Share this topic:
This question is Not Answered
Latest post Thu, Mar 4 2004 4:20 PM by soey. 7 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
soey  +  24535 Thu, 04 Mar 04 04:20 PM
Which one is correct?

I have only ten dollars. or I only have ten dollars.

I only invited ten guest. or I invited only ten guest.
Joined on Thu, Mar 4 2004
New Member 02
rommie  +  24542 Thu, 04 Mar 04 05:02 PM
Every single one of those is a perfectly good sentence.

In order to know which of your choices is "correct", we also need to know exactly what you INTENDED the sentence to mean.
Joined on Mon, Jan 26 2004
Earth orbit
Regular Member 606
gulnur  +  24543 Thu, 04 Mar 04 05:02 PM

I think in the first sentence, the former one is correct- I have only ten dollars.

and in the second sentence I invited only ten guests.
Joined on Thu, Mar 4 2004
New Member 07
konstantin  +  25939 Fri, 19 Mar 04 10:33 AM
I am curious what is the difference between the above sentences. I thought, only one of them would be correct. Since the author hasn't specified what he or she wanted to express, could anyone explain the meaning of each version?
Thanks
Konstantin
Joined on Thu, Mar 18 2004
Nuremberg / Bavaria / Germany
New Member 18
mirapence  +  25941 Fri, 19 Mar 04 12:16 PM
Hello konstantin,

There is a subtle difference in meaning between those sentences.

1. "only" and "I have 10 dollars."

1) I only have 10 dollars.

Suppose you have neither food nor drinks, and alll you have is 10 dollars in your pocket. Sad to say, but "I only have 10 dollars." would turn out to be a fitting expression.

2) I have only 10 dollars.

You may need around 20 dollars to buy a ticket to a baseball game (I'm not sure if you could get a seat in the bleacher under 10 bucks), but all you could manage to get was, alas, 10 dollars. What else would you say, but "I have only 10 dollars."


2. "only" in "I invited 10 guests."

1) I only invited 10 guests.

All you did was invite some guests, but you didn't guarantee them the special treat you prepared for a few. 10 of them are invited anyway.

2) I invited only 10 guests.

Your place could not afford to accomodate more than 10 people. There was no alternative but to invite only ten guests.


My illustration may not cover all situations. I hope you will find it still helpful to have an idea as to the use of the "only".

Joined on Mon, Mar 8 2004
California, U.S.A
Junior Member 77
konstantin, 5 yr 250 days ago
Hi mirapence,
thanks a lot for your answer!

Regards
Konstantin
simon_phlui  +  25982 Sat, 20 Mar 04 01:13 AM
> 1) I only have 10 dollars.
> 2) I have only 10 dollars

Is the following interpretation correct?

In (1), "only" is an adverb that describe "have". So the emphasis
is on the act of possession. The sentence means
"I only have 10 dollars. I have nothing else."

In (2), "only" is an adjective that describe "10 dollars". The emphasis
is on the amount of money. The sentence means
"I have only 10 dollars. The amount is not enough for ..."

The relation is like:
1) I only play the piano. I don't compose music.
2) I play only the piano. I don't play the violin.
Joined on Wed, Dec 10 2003
Junior Member 58
rommie, 5 yr 249 days ago
Yup.
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3614.32638. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.