Past tense or future tense.

   Share on Facebook  
Ajwrighter  #444907  Wed, 21 Nov 07 07:37 PM

Recently I had written a paper and it was graded by a grad student.  On the paper the comments "Stay in one tense. Do not use past AND future tense." were placed next to the Materials and methods title.  Will someone point out exactly where both past and future tense is being used?

Introduction

The purpose of the exercise is to determine if there is a difference in using pH electrode or pH optical sensors when determining an unknown sample.  A 95% confidence interval will be used as determined using values of both the pH electrode and the pH optical.  Once the data has been collected a null and alternative hypothesis will be used to determine if the pH values collected are the same. 

 

Materials and methods

In the procedure the following devices and materials where used; pH electrode, pH optical, Computer, unknown sample, DI water, 7 cuvettes, Phenol Red solution and two standard solutions ph 7.0 and 7.5.  The two standard solutions were used to calibrate the pH electrode sensor.  The pH electrode measured the unknown solution seven times using the 7 cuvettes. After each use the pH electrode sensor was rinsed with DI water so to prevent any contamination.  The data recorded from the measurements will be used for determining the calibration curve.  The reference points used to create the formula from the calibration curve were derived from 2 cuvettes containing a clear solution.  With the formula and the known values, the remaining values for the pH (optical pH sensor) and the Absorbance (pH electrode) could be determined.  With the complete set of data (including mean, standard deviation etc…) a 95% confidence interval on the mean pH was conducted using both pH sensors.  Finally a null and alternative hypothesis was created to determine if the difference between the pH (optical pH sensor) and the values of the pH (pH electrode sensor) are the same.

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Nov 20 2007
New Member (02)
Kooyeen  #444917  Wed, 21 Nov 07 08:26 PM
Hi,
welcome to EF.
I am a non-native speaker, but I tried to read your text very quickly, and I noticed this:
 Ajwrighter wrote:

[...] The data recorded from the measurements will be used for determining the calibration curve.  The reference points used to create the formula from the calibration curve were derived from 2 cuvettes containing a clear solution. With the formula and the known values... [...]


Looks like you had to deal with the calibration curve later. You hadn't already done that when you wrote that paragraph. But the following sentences seem to refer to that calibration curve as something that had already been determined. I can't be 100% sure anyway, because I don't think I understand exactly what you were doing... looks like chemistry, and I don't like chemistry. Wink [;)]


  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Senior Member (4,073)
Moderator
If you don't have a sense of humor already, it's about time you buy one.
Marius Hancu  #444930  Wed, 21 Nov 07 08:56 PM
He was right. Should have stayed just in the past, as this is a past experiement.

The purpose of the exercise is to determine if there is a difference in using pH electrode or pH optical sensors when determining an unknown sample.  A 95% confidence interval will be used as determined using values of both the pH electrode and the pH optical.  Once the data has been collected a null and alternative hypothesis will be used to determine if the pH values collected are the same. 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Apr 26 2006
Montreal, Canada
Veteran Member (11,673)
Proficient Speaker
Ajwrighter  #445602  Fri, 23 Nov 07 09:20 PM
In an introduction, could it not be in future tense regardless if the material was in past tense.  For instance; In a instructors manual regardless of how many times a person has already assembled the item, is the information not placed in a future/present tense format. The manual describes how you will approach the task with the given information not how you have already approached the information. The same holds true to a paper.  The reader is first introduced to the material in a present form, where all information has already taken place. Then the material (the rest of the paper) explains how the procedure took place.  Even in a book involving a story teller where the story takes place in the past.  The introduction always starts off in the present and tells the story about the past. Even if the first words that you read where "Long Long ago..." or "Once upon a time..." the statement clearly suggests that the story starts off in present tense and explains the story of the past.  I argue that this logic can be directly fitted into any paper where all material has already taken place.  Even the word introduce means: "to present (a person, product, etc.) to a particular group of individuals or to the general public for or as if for the first time by a formal act, announcement, series of recommendations or events, etc."  "for the first time." Another words present/future tense.
  
Marius Hancu  #445609  Fri, 23 Nov 07 10:35 PM
If you know so well, why ask here?

The point is to be consistent and you weren't, IMHO:

After each use the pH electrode sensor was rinsed with DI water so to prevent any contamination. *The data recorded from the measurements will be used for determining the calibration curve.

should be replaced by:

After each use the pH electrode sensor was rinsed with DI water so to prevent any contamination. The data recorded from the measurements has been used for determining the calibration curve.


  
Grammar Geek  #445638  Sat, 24 Nov 07 12:45 AM

Are these instructions on how to perform the experiment, or a report describing the results of the experiment?

Either way, you need to stick to one tense.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Pennsylvania, USA
Veteran Member (16,098)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Barbara, who answers in American English.
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service