The past tense vs past perfect!help!

   Share on Facebook  
Eelt  #433102  Sun, 21 Oct 07 05:55 PM

Dear administrators:

     Thanks for help.Since I have known my post working, I have some englsih grammer to ask. Please consider following two sentences:

  1. Did Einstan take IQ test before?

 2. Had Einstan taken IQ test before?

Could you tell me which one is more correct and what the difference is between them?

Thank you and I am looking foward to hearing from you. Have a nice weekend!.Smile [:)]

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Oct 8 2007
taiwan
New Member (32)
ken
Clive  #433120  Sun, 21 Oct 07 07:03 PM

Hi,

Please consider following two sentences:

  1. Did Einstein take an IQ test before?

 2. Had Einstein taken an IQ test before?

Could you tell me which one is more correct and what the difference is between them?

OK, but let me begin by asking you why you have said 'before'. Before what?

Best wishes, Clive

 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (22,568)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Eelt  #433135  Sun, 21 Oct 07 07:22 PM

Hi!Dear Clive:

   Thanks for replying.OK, if I don' t use "before" in the setence, shall I just say:

1. Did Einstein take an IQ test?

2. Had Einstein taken an IQ test?

I was referring to  whether or not Einsten took an IQ test in the past. Which setence should I construct in regrding to this intent? thanks Clive

Your truly

eelt

  
Believer  #433655  Tue, 23 Oct 07 02:07 AM

Thank you, Clive.

I think a long time ago, you mentioned that one of the important caveats in regard to the use of the past perfect is not to use with such words as 'before' or 'after' and from that, I gather what you meant was that with such obvious time references resulting from th use of 'before' and 'after', the past perfect should not be used like this.

I had walked to the post office before last Wednesday.    

But I have seen plenty of cases where what comes after the words 'after' or 'before' is more detailed like this:

I had walked to the post office before I bought a new bike.

Is that how the differentiation is made? Frankly, I don't know the clear distinction between the two. Can you help?

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 2 2006
Contributing Member (1,969)
Clive  #433689  Tue, 23 Oct 07 04:36 AM

Hi eelt,

OK, if I don' t use "before" in the sentence, shall I just say:

1. Did Einstein take an IQ test?

2. Had Einstein taken an IQ test?

I was referring to  whether or not Einsten took an IQ test in the past. Which sentence should I construct in regrding to this intent? You are just asking a simple question about the past, so just use Simple Past tense, ie #1.

Best wishes, Clive

  
Clive  #433695  Tue, 23 Oct 07 04:49 AM

H Believer,

I think a long time ago, you mentioned that one of the important caveats in regard to the use of the past perfect is not to use with such words as 'before' or 'after' and from that, I gather what you meant was that with such obvious time references resulting from th use of 'before' and 'after', the past perfect should not be used like this. Basically, yes. .

I had walked to the post office before last Wednesday.    Yes, don't use it like this.

But I have seen plenty of cases where what comes after the words 'after' or 'before' is more detailed like this:

I had walked to the post office before I bought a new bike. I don't see any need to use Past Perfect here. The sequence of events is obvious without it.

Is that how the differentiation is made? No, it's nothing to do with the level of detail.

Frankly, I don't know the clear distinction between the two. Use it if the sequence is not obvious without it. eg

I read a book. I watched TV for two hours. Here, my understanding is 'first the book, then the TV'.

I read a book. I had watched TV for two hours. Here, my understanding is 'first the TV, then the book'.

It's not quite as simple as this, but these are simple examples to illustrate the main idea.

Best wishes, Clive

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service