We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


1 2 3 4
Share this topic:
This is a discussion thread.
Latest post Wed, Sep 17 2008 8:46 AM by Dejanm83. 28 replies.
| |
Dejanm83  +  500307 Sun, 13 Apr 08 11:08 PM
Is it PC to say "black people"?

 

I'm sorry if I'm repeating the topic, but I tried searching and got hundreds of results, and none in the first couple of pages were relevant.

 

I am an English student from Bosnia and Herzegovina (south-east Europe), and I'm writing a paper on politically correctness, so I need thoughts from Americans...

It is my opinion that "African American" is not precise. It is limited to citizens of America with African heritage. What about black people in other countries in the world? What about black Americans from Cuba, the Carribeans and so on? "Black people" encompasses all those groups.

Can anyone tell me if it is offensive to use "black person/people", and if so, what is the accepted term which would denote the whole group...

 

Thanks! 

Joined on Fri, Nov 17 2006
Bosnia and Herzegowina
New Member 17
Grammar Geek  +  500320 Sun, 13 Apr 08 11:50 PM

Do you know the expression about a pendulum swinging back after it was swung completely one way?

There was a time when only "African-American" would do. My children have been taught that, to the point they don't know any other term - making it absurd when we were in another part of the world and they used the term there.

There are mixed opinions among those with darker skin themselves as to what to call themselves. Some will say Blacks with a capital b, some will say black wih a lower-case b, and some will prefer to use only African-American. One of my daughters has - for the first time - a black teacher and she seems to be teacher a bit more than math, which is great considering you can count the number of black kids in their elementry school on one hand. (Maybe two hands, I haven't actually tried to do it.) It seems Miss R uses the term "black people" for her 9-year-old students.

My good friend at work is black. I don't often find it necessary to refer to race, but I use "black" with her. I would use "African-American" with someone I didn't know very well, so it seems that's still the most politically correct form.

However, the black experience in the US has historically been a very different experience than in other places, so I don't see a problem having two phrases, one for the US and one for other places. if you really felt that you had to be sensitive and wanted to refer to places other than the US, then use "those of African descent."

(Note that simply "Africans" implies that they or their parents are from the US - to be an "African-American" implies generations have been here. Probably more generations than most white Americans.)

You will not fine ONE term that is always right. You will find many terms that are always wrong, however. "Colored" is considered an old-fashioned term and slighly prejudiced. Negro sounds like you're from the 1960s. And the "n-word" is considered so offensive that many people who use the "f-word" without pause but will never use the n-word.

Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Veteran Member 19,652
Barbara, who answers in American English. My housekeeping skills attest to the truth of the second law of thermodynamics: Left to themselves, things get more and more random!
Clive  +  500321 Sun, 13 Apr 08 11:55 PM

Hi,

I hear 'people of colour' a lot. Sometimes it seems to be used to refer to all "non-white" people, and other times to "black" people.

You might also be interested in another issue that came up here in Toronto a few weeks ago. One of our councillors referred to Chinese people as 'Orientals'. Some people, including some Chinese -Canadians, complained that this was a racist and offensive term, while othe people, including some Chinese-Canadians, said that it was not.

Best wishes, Clive

Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member 29,580
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Dejanm83  +  500501 Mon, 14 Apr 08 12:17 PM
"There are mixed opinions among those with darker skin themselves as to what to call themselves. Some will say Blacks with a capital b, some will say black wih a lower-case b, and some will prefer to use only African-American."

I'm interested in some estimates as to how many African Americans would be offended with the term black people, capital B or not - 10, 20, 50, 70%?

Since I am so far away, I can't exactly perform a survey, so I need "inside information" :)

 

As for "people of colour", I doubt it is considered any different than "black people", since it isn't different essentially. It sounds as a misguided attempt to be PC...

Clive  +  500522 Mon, 14 Apr 08 01:07 PM

Hi,

Aren't all attempts to be PC misguided?

If the use of a phrase were a good idea, you wouldn't call it PC.

Clive

Dejanm83  +  500545 Mon, 14 Apr 08 01:44 PM
Well, I think the idea behind PC is fine, being sensitive to the feelings of others and trying to avoid derrogative labels, but I'm exploring when PC goes too far. 

For example, I read somewhere that a coffee shop waiter refused to serve a customer who ordered black coffee until they asked for coffee without milk. Or when people frown when someone uses the word renig, which means to go back on a deal and is much much older than "***"...

I realize identity is fluid, and that different members of the same group have different opinions, but there has to be some stance majority when it comes to "black person".

Clive  +  500754 Mon, 14 Apr 08 09:46 PM

Hi,

renig,  It's spelled renege.

I wasn't arguing that the idea behind political correctness is necessarily wrong. I just meant that the term, the words themselves, are considered pejorative. eg

If I think the term 'yyyyyy' is a good idea, I'll say that it is an appropriate and useful term.

But if I don't like the term 'yyyyyy', I'll say that it is politically correct.

Best wishes, Clive

Dejanm83  +  500805 Mon, 14 Apr 08 11:44 PM
"It's spelled renege"

EmbarrassedEmbarrassedEmbarrassed 

My bad, I took the sound and similarity for granted - maybe an indicator of the white frame of mind :D

 

Interesting remarks though... Can I quote you on that? :) 

But I am still without answers as to the majority's view of the term "black people"...

Clive  +  500813 Tue, 15 Apr 08 12:11 AM

Hi again,

Can I quote you on that? :) Sure

But I am still without answers as to the majority's view of the term "black people"... I usuually hear this form just as 'blacks'. Seems fine to me.

Clive

1 2 3 4
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.