Possessive

   Share on Facebook  
New2grammar  #384504  Tue, 26 Jun 07 05:25 PM

There's a car engine sitting on the floor of my garage and I would say:

1. The car engine is still in good condition though it looks old.

If there's a car instead of just a car engine in my garage, to emphasize that the engine belongs to the car, I would say:

2. The car's engine is still in good condition though it looks older than the car itself.

If my interpretation is correct, #1 shouldn't take the possive form because it misleads the listener to think there's a car in the garage and the speaker is refering to the engine in the car.

Is my usage of the possesive form correct?

Thanks in advance!

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Nov 21 2006
Veteran Member (7,676)
Who wants to go sailing around the world with me?
Doll  #384529  Tue, 26 Jun 07 07:05 PM

Your sentences are correct. And I wouldn't comment #1 as you do.Smile [:)]

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Mar 10 2007
Turkey
Senior Member (2,579)
Moderator
I am a netizen!
New2grammar  #384661  Wed, 27 Jun 07 02:53 AM

Do you mean you don't agree with my interpretation hightlighted in red below? What's your interpretation then?

There's a car engine sitting on the floor of my garage and I would say:

1. The car engine is still in good condition though it looks old.

If there's a car instead of just a car engine in my garage, to emphasize that the engine belongs to the car, I would say:

2. The car's engine is still in good condition though it looks older than the car itself.

If my interpretation is correct, #1 shouldn't take the possive form because it misleads the listener to think there's a car in the garage and the speaker is refering to the engine in the car.

  
Doll  #385139  Thu, 28 Jun 07 01:42 AM

Hi dear,  

If you want to give( or emphasize) the meaning that there is a car in the garage and the engine belong's to it, you say the car's engine.....   However, if you just say the car engine..., it may not give you the meaning that there is a car in the garage and it belongs to it. You may be talking only about a car engine.    

This is how I comment it.Smile [:)]

Ps: compare the engine of the car vs the car engine. I think car's engine is wrong.

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service