Possessive s

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Mjomran  #219039  Sun, 23 Apr 06 08:00 PM

Hi all,

Regarding "possessive s", I usually follow the following rule: use 's with animate objects, organization,/company/club/etc and days. Is this rule correct?

Thanks

Best wishes

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sun, Apr 23 2006
New Member (07)
Muayad Jajo  #219060  Sun, 23 Apr 06 09:13 PM
correct
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Mar 20 2006
Junior Member (76)
Even Homer sometimes nods
Mjomran  #219083  Sun, 23 Apr 06 10:33 PM

Thank you very much.

Just to make the rule clearer I will use 's with animate objects, organization/club/company/country (i.e. any thing that have animate objects) and dates. However, I wont use 's with anything else (e.g. chair leg, book cover, etc).

Best wishes 

  
Grammar Geek  #219085  Sun, 23 Apr 06 10:42 PM

No, the possessive 's can be used with inanimate objects - the book's cover was badly torn. That one of the table's legs was a little shorter than the others so it was wobbly.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Pennsylvania, USA
Veteran Member (16,067)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Barbara, who answers in American English.
Mjomran  #219087  Sun, 23 Apr 06 10:53 PM
Thanks Grammar Geek. So should I use 's with everything (animate/inanimate)?
  
Grammar Geek  #219435  Mon, 24 Apr 06 09:32 PM

I was thinking about this after I posted. This is another area that as a native speaker I have never considered before.

You CAN (may) use it with all items, but you can also say "The table leg is scratched" or "The book cover is torn."  When you want to differentiate between THIS table versus THAT table, you would use the possessive 's.  When you want to draw attention to the fact that it was that particular object you are describing. 

"I liked the table they had on the sales floor, but that table's leg was scratched, so I bought this other one instead."

"The book's cover was torn off, so I knew the author wouldn't get any royalties if I bought it."  "The book's cover showed an almost-naked lady. No wonder it sold so well!"

Does that help at all?

  
YoHf  #219441  Mon, 24 Apr 06 09:50 PM

It can be used with (usually) big cities, too.

 Grammar Geek wrote:

"The book's cover showed an almost-naked lady. No wonder it sold so well!"

No wonder at all. May I ask you what was that book's title G²? :rotfl:

Music [8]

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Oct 26 2005
Florence, Italy
Senior Member (3,345)
To be yourself is all that you can do. Music [8]
Grammar Geek  #219444  Mon, 24 Apr 06 09:56 PM
Uh huh, YoHf... and how many people purchased Sheherazade as their first classical music recording for the same reason? Wink [;)]
  
Mjomran  #219710  Tue, 25 Apr 06 07:06 PM
Thank you very much for the clarification. Now it is more clearer.
  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service