Present perfect progressive tense/ passive voice?

This question has no verified answers · 7 replies
Could any advisor please make a sentence for me using the present perfect progressive tense with a passive vioce?

LCChang
Northern Taiwan
Contributing Member 1,109
Life will never end.
Hi,

I took my car in to the garage a week ago. Every time I call them, they say they are fixing it.

They have been fixing my car for the last week.

My car has been being fixed for the last week.

Best wishes, Clive
Canada
Veteran Member 52,307
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Times are bad. Factories can no longer make a profit unless they lay off employees. At one local factory, nearly fifty employees have been being laid off every month.

Over the last three weeks the maple trees have been being tapped in preparation for the syrup harvest.

All evidence points to the fact that the child has been being bullied at school, and the parents are going to sue unless something is done about it.

CJ
California
Veteran Member 39,240
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Great sentences!! Thanks.

LCChang
Northern Taiwan
Contributing Member 1,109
Life will never end.
I took my car in to the garage a week ago. Every time I call them, they say they are fixing it.

Is it a typo? Can "into" be written as two words?
Taiwan
Full Member 348
Thank you very much for your reply.


Could any advisor please make a sentence for me using the present perfect progressive tense with a passive vioce?

I remember reading in many traditional grammar books that it is incorrect to use these tenses in the passive voice. As they don't seem to bother native speakers' ears, times may be changing! I avoid them, though.

CB
Finland
Veteran Member 6,660
Newt Gingrich, criticizing Mitt Romney, his rival for the US presidency: "He speaks French!"
Can "into" be written as two words?
No. It's not into in that case; it's two words, in and to.

to take a car in is to take it to a repair shop or to the car dealer where you bought it for the purpose of having it repaired or for a check-up. It's a phrasal verb. bring in works the same. garage can be used for car repair shop.

The sentence in question is not talking about moving the car into a garage.

Phone call to the repair shop (i.e., to the 'garage').

-- My turn signal isn't working.
-- Well, bring it in Friday. We'll take a look.
___

-- I took my car in for repairs last Wednesday.
-- Which garage do you usually
take it in to?
-- I take it in to the dealer on Tenth Street.

Similarly,

I have to take the dog in to the veterinarian for a check-up next Tuesday.
You received the vase by mail, and it was broken? Bring it in to our shop, and we'll give you a refund.


CJ
California
Veteran Member 39,240
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Anonymous:
The car has been taken by me to the garage