Present Perfect questions

   Share on Facebook  
Tania E.  #129643  Mon, 22 Aug 05 04:27 PM
It's raining. Two people are looking out the window. One of them says....:

#1: It has been raining a lot this week
#2: It has rained a lot this week

According to most of my sources #2 should be correct (and #1 is wrong), but i also found somewhere that #1 is correct as well....is this true?


another question....

what's the difference between...

[CNN reports...]
We've been listening to greek radio         <- this is what CNN said....
VS
We've listened to greek radio               <- what if they said this?

[CNN reports....]
we have been reporting that John was involved in the accident, this was not true       <- what cnn said....
VS
We have reported that John was involved in the accident, this was not true


I believe PPC means "lately" or "recently"

Thanks in advance
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Aug 22 2005
New Member (03)
Anonymous  #129645  Mon, 22 Aug 05 04:32 PM
If it is raining at the time the appropriate expression would be #2 I has been raining a lot this week.
  
Pal  #129650  Mon, 22 Aug 05 04:43 PM
 Tania E. wrote:
It's raining. Two people are looking out the window. One of them says....:

#1: It has been raining a lot this week
#2: It has rained a lot this week

According to most of my sources #2 should be correct (and #1 is wrong), but i also found somewhere that #1 is correct as well....is this true?


#1 is correct.
Both of them are grammatically correct.  #1 means that it rained a lot this week, it is still raining, and it is likely to rain in the near future.  #2 means it rained a lot this week, and it stopped raining now.

Same explanation applies to your next two questions.  It's really the difference between present perfect tense and present perfect progresive tense

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Aug 16 2005
New Member (10)
I'm not a native English speaker.
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions