Forums · General English Grammar & Vocabulary, Listening & Speaking · General English Grammar Questions
I know that dictionaries say that the "g" and "c" refer to different phonetic symbols. But I cannot hear a difference!
Also, I find it impossible to pronounce a hard "g" sound immediately after an "s" smoothly. Is it true?
Anonymous:Yes, that's a good observation. In actual pronunciation, there is in practice no difference between 'disgust' and 'discussed'.
That is because after the sound /s/, the distinction between the voiced/voiceless pairs like /d/ and /t/, /b/ and /p/, and /g/ and /k/ is neutralized. A voiceless consonant that follows /s/ loses aspiration, the 'h'-like puff that usually accompanies the voiceless consonants like /t/, /p/, and /k/ in English, while after /s/ you can't really have voiced consonants, in which your vocal cords vibrate. So the means of distinguishing the voiced and voiceless consonants are lost in this environment.
Nevertheless, dictionaries usually transcribe the pronunciations of 'disgust' and 'discussed' differently because the idea is that the underlying sounds (at an abstract level, as evidenced by the spelling) are different, even if they come out the same.
The Longman Pronunciation Dictionary notes a possible pronunciation where you would use the sequence /-zg-/ for 'disgust', and in this rare case you would actually pronounce the pair differently.
The following blog post is about whether to transcribe similar sequences in Welsh as /sd/ or /st/, and it mentions the same point about English in passing, even using the same example of 'disgust' and 'discussed'.
fivejedjon'Disgust' and 'discussed' can therefore sound very similar indeed.Yes, but definitely not identical.
Anonymous:Yes. But, the difference in meaning could be problematic
People are waiting to help.
Live chatRegistered users can join here
Related forum topics:
Difference between dinner and supper?Plural of nouns: Pronunciation.?What is the difference between love and...Difference between THERE and IT?difference between polysemy and homonymy?The difference between 'because' and 'Since'?Difference between Chat and Talk?pronunciation?difference between quotation and proverb?difference between the meaning of ''shia'' and...difference between ''in time'' and ''on time''?Difference between in and on?difference between ''anyways'' and ''anyway''?difference between British, Briton, and English?difference in meaning between ''It is raining...difference between ''round'' and ''around''?difference between ''genius'' and ''ingenious''?the difference between can and could?Difference between phonics and phonetics?Difference between Linux and Windows HostingDifference between TO and FOR?Is there a big difference between "v" and "b"...Difference between IT'S and IT IS.?