Always preserve the quote. If Jim's full quote was "the chicken tasted like death", then that is how you report it.
Square brackets [ ] are used to make changes to a quote. If the quote contains a pronoun, for example, you can use the name that it refers to in the brackets to avoid confusion.
If the quote is "he said the chicken tasted like death." To clarify, it should be changed to "[Jim] said the chicken tasted like death."
If the quote is "Jim said the chicken tasted like death." then no changes should be made, and you don't need brackets.