Click here to play

Register

   Share on Facebook  
maverick88  #77297  Mon, 28 Feb 05 05:14 PM
Could you please tell me which sentence of the following is of a higher register?
1. The closet was used to store clothes.
2. The closet was used for storing slothes.
Thanks
  
Top 100 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Nov 22 2004
Israel
Regular Member (695)
An English learner
nona the brit  #77339  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:17 PM
Hi Maverick,

I don't understand what you mean by 'higher register' and from the lack of responses I guess no one else does either. Can you explain again what you want?
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Sep 22 2004
England
Veteran Member (11,345)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
The name says it all.
maverick88  #77340  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:30 PM
Hi Nona,
As I understood from some replies, a register is a certain level of English. The higher the register is the more (grammatically) proper or acceptable the sentence is.
So I just asked which sentence would be better to use.
  
nona the brit  #77342  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:36 PM
Well...
I'd say

1. The closet (well I wouldn't because that is American but I'll use my imagination) was used to store clothes.

2.The closet was used to store clothes in.

3.The closet was used for storing clothes.

With my preference being for number 3.
  
maverick88  #77343  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:39 PM
Well, thanks and another Q:
Would you say about an inanimate object "...is used to storing clothes"?
  
nona the brit  #77345  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:43 PM
No

'be + used + to' means to be accustomed to something. This would mean that the object had feelings about storing clothes.
  
maverick88  #77348  Mon, 28 Feb 05 11:51 PM
What about 'is used to store'?
The closet is used [by people] to store clothes [in].
Is it OK?
This time it looks like passive, doesn't it?
  
nona the brit  #77356  Tue, 01 Mar 05 12:12 AM
Ah yes in this case it is ok. Sorry.

It is is 'used to 'ing' that means accustomed to.
  
maverick88  #77357  Tue, 01 Mar 05 12:14 AM
Thank you very much, Nona.
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service