Click here to play!

Relative clause

Click here to play
1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Liveinjapan  #335954  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:28 PM

Hi, teachers.

I found the line below in the magazine called The Best of the Larry King Live from CNN.

This is the interview with Ms. Clinton.

'..., I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way it should be resolved are the votes of the people who acturally voted in the election.'

"it should be resolved" is a relative clause, isn't it? I think  it refers to 'the best evidence of the way'. Can I replace 'it' by 'that' or 'which'?

'I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way which(/that) should be resolved are the votes of the people who acturally voted in the election.'

Thanks in advance.

  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Sun, Feb 4 2007
Osaka, Japan
Contributing Member (1,546)
Please feel free to correct any words I wrote.LiJ
Clive  #335958  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:37 PM

Hi,

'..., I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way it should be resolved are the votes of the people who acturally voted in the election.'

"it should be resolved" is a relative clause, isn't it? Yes

I think  it refers to 'the best evidence of the way'. No. 'It' refers to the problem/situation that she is talking about, and which she has mentioned earlier in this sentence or perhaps in a previous sentence.

Can I replace 'it' by 'that' or 'which'? You can't say 'which' because of what I just said. You could say 'that', referring to 'that problem/situation I mentioned earlier'.

Best wishes, Clive

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (20,438)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Anonymous  #335959  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:37 PM
 Liveinjapan wrote:

 I think  it refers to 'the best evidence of the way'.

'It' refers to something (a problem? a concern? an issue?) that has already been mentioned (you need to check what preceeds your quotation).

You can re-write:

'I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way in which it should be resolved are the votes of the people who actually voted in the election.'


S.

  
Liveinjapan  #335966  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:49 PM

I understand Clive, and S. thak you very much.

This sentence was a little difficult for me, but your answer really helps me.

The privious clause is this: For me, I'm hoping that when this is finally resolved and, of course, I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way it shoul be resolved are the votes ..........

This is the full sentence. I should have written a full sentence, but you really helped me. I understand that 'it' refers to the 'Problem' which is not written here. Does 'this' also refer to the 'Problem'?

Thanks.

  
Anonymous  #335967  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:50 PM
 Liveinjapan wrote:

I think  it refers to 'the best evidence of the way'.

Well, I've checked the transcript (http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0012/11/lkl.00.html)

"KING: So if it's George Bush raising his right hand, there's no biting of the bottom lip?

CLINTON: Not for me. For me, I'm hoping that when this is finally resolved -- and, of course, I believe strongly that the best evidence of the way it should be resolved are the votes of the people who actually voted in the election. But it is in the courts. And when it is resolved, certainly, you know, I'm prepared to serve with and to -- you know, to watch whoever the next president is swear loyalty to our Constitution."

She's talking about the controversy about the results of the 2000 election. At the time she was speaking, they were counting the votes again.


S.

  
Clive  #335972  Mon, 05 Mar 07 04:57 PM

Hi,

Yes.

Clive

  
Liveinjapan  #335974  Mon, 05 Mar 07 05:02 PM

Wow!

Thanks Clive and S.

I'll probably never understand it without your answers. Thank you very much.

  
Anonymous  #335977  Mon, 05 Mar 07 05:09 PM

You're welcome!


S.

  
Kooyeen  #336025  Mon, 05 Mar 07 06:37 PM
Hi,
since someone asked a related question some days ago, I think it's interesting to notice that Ms. Clinton said that the best evidence are the votes of the people who acturally voted in the election (instead of "the best evidence is the votes"). Not that "is" would have been wrong, it's just that "are" sounded better to her (I guess). Smile [:)]

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Senior Member (3,832)
Moderator
If you don't have a sense of humor already, it's about time you buy one.
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions