Home
Forums
Tests
Friends
ESL Chat
Pics
Videos
Forums
»
ESL, Rules of English Grammar, Help and Games
»
ESL General English Grammar Questions
»
Relative pronoun definition: He "what" runs
Relative pronoun definition: He "what" runs
1
2
3
Share on Facebook
Arnkell
#87867 Thu, 07 Apr 05 05:42 PM
What are the rules for using "what" in the way I did in this thread title?
I first heard it in the TV cartoon series "The Tick", which has a bad guy called "The Midnight Bomber What Bombs At Midnight".
I've been told that the standard pronouns are who, whom, which and that:
"Who" is used for people
"Whom" is used as an object about people or after prepositions
"Whose" is a genitive and can refer to both people and things
"Which" refers to things, animals or a whole sentence
"That" can be a substitute for both "Who" and "Which" in relative clauses when necessary
But what about "What";
The man what is called John
The Bomber what bombs at midnight
Does anyone know the rules for using "What" in this way?
Arnkell
Joined on Thu, Apr 7 2005
Stockholm, Sweden
New Member
(
04
)
Select Tags...
Save
Cancel
Prepositions
,
Clauses
,
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
,
Whom
,
Genitives
khoff
#87881 Thu, 07 Apr 05 06:02 PM
I would say the rule is to use "what" instead of "who" or "that" if you want to sound illiterate or uneducated!
khoff
Joined on Sun, Mar 6 2005
Denver, Colorado, USA, Earth
Senior Member
(
2,615
)
Native speaker of American English (but not a grammar expert)
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
Clauses
Is there any relative pronoun omitted?
What kind of clause?
Relative Clause
A Relative Pronoun
Relative pronouns: who/whom
About an ellipsis of relative pronoun
Relative clauses
Relative pronoun question
Relative clauses and participles
What does relative pronoun 'which' represent...
A question about whose and relative clauses
Arnkell
#87896 Thu, 07 Apr 05 06:18 PM
What makes you associate this "What"-use with being illiterate and uneducated? I thought it was an older way of speaking, like saying "thee"?!
Arnkell
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
just the truth
#87959 Thu, 07 Apr 05 11:19 PM
What makes you associate this "What"-use with being illiterate and uneducated? I thought it was an older way of speaking, like saying "thee"?!
JTT: If I'm not mistaken, it is an older form of English. It's funny and more than a bit ironic that the language that is often made most fun of [hill country] more closely replicates older forms of English.
just the truth
Joined on Mon, Dec 27 2004
Regular Member
(
849
)
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
just the truth
#87960 Thu, 07 Apr 05 11:20 PM
I forgot to say that it isn't standard English.
just the truth
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
Arnkell
#87971 Thu, 07 Apr 05 11:42 PM
Right, I had deduced that as well, I like reading about old nuggets like "pray tell" and "fair teeming" and such, which is why this "what" thing caught my eye.
My generation of swedish youths is so used to modern english-american lingo that quaint, old fashioned expressions and colloquial figures of speech shine like pearls when we happen upon them.
It's not like I would use this expression any chance I get, that would sound pretentious as all hell, but I thought it would be interesting to see if there was any backstory to be found about the manner of this pronoun, like during which period it was most used and by which part of the english-speaking population.
Do you know how hard it is to try and hunt down linguistic web articles about aged relative pronouns on Google? It's a lot of work, I tell you.
Arnkell
Articles
,
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Expressions
,
Relative Pronouns
khoff
#87978 Fri, 08 Apr 05 12:10 AM
Sorry - I had a feeling when I made the "illiterate and uneducated" comment I was going to regret it! I didn't even think of the posiblity of its being archaic. Pray forgive, forsooth!
khoff
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
MrPedantic
#87980 Fri, 08 Apr 05 12:36 AM
Only a guess: but if we take 'what' to mean 'that which', can we call the 'older/hill people' use a kind of restatement? e.g.
1. The play what I wrote =>
2. The play that which I wrote.
'What' seems an unjustly maligned little word. In BrE, for instance, 'which' seems to be regarded as somehow more upmarket; so you might hear e.g.
3. 'I don't know which play you mean',
instead of
4. 'I don't know what play you mean'.
Or, monstrously, e.g.
5. 'I don't know to which play you're referring',
instead of
6. 'I don't know what play you're referring to'.
MrP
MrPedantic
Joined on Tue, Oct 12 2004
Veteran Member
(
12,167
)
...opella forensis / adducit febris...
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
CalifJim
#88038 Fri, 08 Apr 05 04:16 AM
Mr. P.,
I thought that "what" in that usage was very "East End London". Can you confirm?
Example: You have an aura what is purple with white stripes.
CJ
CalifJim
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member
(
17,714
)
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Nouns
,
Pronouns
,
Relative Pronouns
1
2
3
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions
&
Terms of Service