Right and correct

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #172024  Tue, 20 Dec 05 01:27 AM

Hi, folks,

Could you tell me when I can use the word "correct"  instead of  "right" ?

For example : Your answer is right or Your answer is correct.

    Thanks                  

    

 

  
This is a live chat room, hosted on the chat page. You can also click here to see the chat in fullscreen.
TammyBaby  #172109  Tue, 20 Dec 05 05:39 AM
"Right" and "correct" are synonyms! But "correct" is more formal than "right". You can use one of them with answers, facts, methods... etc. Both of your examples are ok! "Correct" and "right" mean they contain no mistakes or break no rules. But do NOT use "correct" about people. Use "right".

For example: "You are right" - nobody uses "You are correct."

Is my explanation clear? Hope it helps!

Tammy
 
  
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Jul 27 2005
Winterland - land of cold, memories and dreams...
Full Member (332)
TammyBaby - Nothing is impossible!Life changes when we change!A secret makes a woman woman!
Anonymous  #173068  Thu, 22 Dec 05 01:03 AM

Big Smile [:D] Very clear! Thank you very much Tammy!

Luciana (Brasil)

 

  
Anonymous  #173073  Thu, 22 Dec 05 01:12 AM
My question was answered. Thanks Tammy.   
  
paco2004  #173181  Thu, 22 Dec 05 09:38 AM
 TammyBaby wrote:
But do NOT use "correct" about people. Use "right".
For example: "You are right" - nobody uses "You are correct." 

Hello Tammy Baby

I am surprised to know your answer is different from what is written in my dictionary. My dictionary (Oxford English Dictionary, 2002 CD version) is rather old one and it describes usages of words in the Great Britain's dialect of English. So I'm afraid the explanation of "correct" in the dictionary might be wrong. Do you think I had better throw this bad dictionary into a garbage box?

correct : adjective
2. in accordance with fact, truth, or reason; free from error; exact, true, accurate; right. Said also of persons, in reference to their statements, scholarship, acquirements, etc.

[1705 Addison] Monsieur Misson has wrote a more correct Account of Italy than any before him. [1711 H. Felton], Always use the most correct editions.  [1790 C. M. Graham] The correctest idea we can form of the equity of our maker.  [1820 in Picton L'pool Munic] Leaving to their correcter judgment to decide. [1831 Macaulay]  Mr. Hunt is, we suspect, quite correct in saying that.  [1875 Jevons Money]This definition will be correct.  [1875 Ure] When the author returns his proof and revise, and is satisfied that the sheet is correct. [1875 Ure] Care is taken that the pages are correct, and that the ‘signatures’ are in order.  [1882 Croker] On reference to the correct card, they saw 'Captain Campbell's Tornado; scarlet jacket, etc.' 

paco

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Nov 17 2004
Senior Member (4,095)
In Japan today even dogs are learning how to bow-wow in English.
TammyBaby  #173321  Thu, 22 Dec 05 07:15 PM
Hey paco,

Your question makes me have to open my dictionary. Thanks God what I remember is right! I read it from Longman Essential Activator. It can be called Synonyms dictionary. Uhm, I think you should take a look at it. Your dictionary and mine are not published from 1 publisher. So I can not say which is correct! Crying [:'(] Uhm, I just checked Oxford Advanced Learners' Dictionary 2004 and it's like you said. The example in O.A.L.D 2004: "Am I correct in saying that you know a lot about wine?" Uhm, dictionaries from Longman and Oxford give different explanation from each other. Crying [:'(] But in my opinion, we should use "right" about people because Oxford Dic. does not say that we only can use "correct" about people while Longman Dic. avoid "correct" in this situation. Uhm, it's mad!

What's your opinion, paco? Waiting for your answer!

Tammy
  
paco2004  #173389  Fri, 23 Dec 05 02:57 AM
Hello Tammy

I don't know which dictionary is right (or correct Smile [:)] ). Some dictionaries might be edited prescriptively and others descriptively. Etymologically speaking, "be correct" is "be set/made right". So using it about persons seems a bit weird. However, it is true that actually many people use  "be correct" even when talking about persons. I googled two collocations "he was correct when he said" and "he was right when he said" in three kind of domains. The results are :
         AU : "he was correct when he said":23 sites, "he was right when he said":65 hits
         UK : "he was correct when he said":7 sites, "he was right when he said": 325 hits
         Edu : "he was correct when he said":64 sites, "he was right when he said": 73 hits
AU= Australian domains. UK=UK domains, Edu=US Educational domains

paco
  
TammyBaby  #173403  Fri, 23 Dec 05 03:47 AM
Hi paco,

Thanks for your information! It's really useful and interesting. English is open and it's not surprised when sometimes, it's mad! lolz! Anyway, we should use "right" or "correct" following most people, because of our safety. Lolz! Just a kid! US people are very easy going in using words while UK people seem rather strict. So... uhm, I think in using English words, we should be more careful in UK and can be more freely in US.

Ah, Merry Christmas, paco!

Tammy
  
paco2004  #173436  Fri, 23 Dec 05 08:04 AM
Have yourself a merry Christmas, Tammy!

paco
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL Basic English Grammar Questions and Help
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service