What did he say? What was it he said?

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #498591  Wed, 09 Apr 08 04:42 PM

I have a question about Grammar that has been perplexing me for a while, and hopefully the good people out there who know better English than I do might be able to help me!

 This actually came to me while I was reading a badly translated script, which is unimportant, but it made me think;

Why is it that we say, "What did he/she say?" or "What did I say?" even when it is past tense?

When something has been said, then shouldn't it be "What did I said" even though this sounds grammatically incorrect to me.

However, as I understand it, you would use the phrase "I said", "What was it he [had] said?" and the like.

As a follow-up question to those kind enough to answer, is there a difference between 'do' and 'have' that allows the different conjugation of the verb 'to say' in the different examples, or is this just simply a case of the strange way grammar works?

 Any help is of course, greatly appreciated. Thanking the responders in advance.

  
Philip  #498605  Wed, 09 Apr 08 04:59 PM
Why is it that we say, "What did he/she say?" or "What did I say?" even when it is past tense?
   We use 'did' in making a past tense sentence interrogative or negative, using the base form of the verb.

As a follow-up question to those kind enough to answer, is there a difference between 'do' and 'have' that allows the different conjugation of the verb 'to say' in the different examples, or is this just simply a case of the strange way grammar works?
   What did you say ~ What have you said.




  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
USA Pacific Northwest (Seattle)
Veteran Member (5,617)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
If one will scoff at the study of language, how, save in terms of language, will one scoff? - Mario Pei
CalifJim  #498679  Wed, 09 Apr 08 09:08 PM
 The auxiliary verb carries the tense. did shows the past.  (Otherwise it would be do or does.) You can't indicate tense twice in the same clause.  (*What did I said?)  The main verb shows the past tense ONLY when no auxiliary verb is present to do the job!  (I said so.)

CJ 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (16,003)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Anonymous  #498738  Thu, 10 Apr 08 12:50 AM

Thank you very much for the swift and consise reply.

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions