Hi,
The majority of my club's new English learners often generalize
B of A = A's B or vice versa
. The formulae do not always work as Grammar Geek pointed out. I use them sparingly unless I sense that B is a member of A set, such as:
the cadets of the school = the school's cadets, or
the windows of the house = the house's windows; or an ownership - for example,
the cottage of the Jones = the Jones's cottage. Even with that guide, I wonder whether an exception does exist!?
Regarding genitive case, the word
genitive is broader than the term
possessive. Below are a few examples:
John's house = the house that John owns (simple ownership).
John's block = the block that John lives on (John does not own the block, unless he is a gangster or mafia boss).
The children's books = the books that are written for the children (the children do not own the books).
The slaves' master = the master owns the slaves (the possessive is for the possessed rather than the possessor).
That said, I wish I could find a way to pin down a few rules of thumb that we can all rely on. So far, I've not been able to do so
![Smile [:)]](/emoticons/emotion-1.gif)
.
Best Regards,
Hoa Thai