Sentence analysis

   Share on Facebook  
Guest  #57708  Fri, 26 Nov 04 11:57 PM
Hello I would like to know if anyone can help with these two sentences:

1. "The General Medical Council cannot investigate every council treatment brought to its attention" - From "every controversial...." is that DO/NP or DO/CLAUSE

2. "Until the law was passed, the agency could only use gentle persuasion to get industries to reduce waste" - same question - From "gentle...." DO/NP OR DO/CLAUSE

How can I tell if something is a clause or not? I know that is has something to dto with -that, -which, -who and there are -ing-clauses. But do you know some simple rule? My grammar book is very complicated.Crying [:'(]
  
CalifJim  #57720  Sat, 27 Nov 04 01:54 AM
You need a verb to have a clause.

I think you meant "The GMC cannot investigate every controversial treatment brought to its attention".

[NP every controversial treatment [CLAUSE [NP PRO (which) ] [VP (is) brought [PP to its attention]] ] ]

The clause serves an adjectival function, but the structure as a whole is a noun phrase functioning as direct object within the entire sentence.

______

... use gentle persuasion to get industries to reduce waste.

[ VP use [NP gentle persuasion ]

[ CLAUSE [ NP PRO (agency)] [VP to get [ CLAUSE [NP industries ] [ VP to reduce [NP waste] endVP] endCLAUSE ] endVP] endCLAUSE] endVP]

This verb phrase has a clause within another clause. The outer clause is a causative ("get"), so it has an inner clause "industries to reduce waste" which is the direct object of the causative. The whole outer clause "to get industries ..." is an adverbial adjunct to the verb phrase which precedes it (adverbial of purpose).

_______

This isn't nearly as complicated as a real linguist would see it! Smile [:)]
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (17,792)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service