Shall or Should?

   Share on Facebook  
Guest  #24460  Wed, 03 Mar 04 09:48 PM
You know, it's not my English is bad or something... although I know where to use it.... I would be happy to know jsut the diffrence between Shall and Should.

As I said, I know where to use it.... it sounds logical so I know where to put one of these words.


Thanks alot
  
rommie  #24489  Thu, 04 Mar 04 09:20 AM
This question has a complicated answer, so I'll give the formal answer first. This is still in wide use, particularly in Britain, and particularly in written literature.

In formal English,and in the first person:
"shall" denotes future tense. It is synonymous with "am going to".
"should" means "ought to", and implies an obligation
"will" denotes future tense, but also implies emphasis, or a determination to succeed.
"would" denotes conditional mood, and is used for hypothetical situations.

In formal English, and in the second and third person:
"shall" denotes future tense, but also implies emphasis, or a determination to succeed.
"should" denotes conditional mood, and is used for hypothetical situations.
"will" denotes future tense. It is synonymous with "am going to".
"would" means "ought to", and implies an obligation

Modern usage, particularly in America, and particularly in spoken English, is a little bit more muddied, hence the confusion. So:

In modern, informal English, especially in America, and regardless of person:
"shall" is rarely used.
"should" means "ought to", and implies an obligation
"will" denotes future tense. It is synonymous with "am going to".
"would" denotes conditional mood, and is used for hypothetical situations.

Basically, it's a mess. In order to get it right you need to know your audience.
Rommie
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 26 2004
Earth orbit
Regular Member (606)
MGMarcoe  #24614  Fri, 05 Mar 04 03:41 AM
To muddle it further, remember that "shall" is present tense and "should" is
past tense. However, these two facts really mean very little these days.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sat, Nov 29 2003
Eau Claire, Wis.
New Member (07)
rommie  #24663  Fri, 05 Mar 04 09:40 AM
To muddle it further, remember that "shall" is present tense and "should" is
past tense.


I disagree with both of these assertions. They are both either future tense or conditional.
Rommie
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service